India Accuses Pakistan for Weaponising the OIC - Voted Against OIC in UN

For us relegion lies above nationality.. that’s the fact even if any one like it or not.. It can be a problem for u or any other relegion.. I don’t blame u or ur country man.. it’s ur instinct to question ur fellow countryman Muslim loyality.. if ur fellow country man is a true Muslim for him relegion should lie above nationality..
Fair enough, but aren't you making the case for those who distrust Muslims yourself? If you're openly saying a Muslim's loyalty to his religious brotherhood comes before his own country, even when that brotherhood includes people across hostile borders, why would you expect his fellow countrymen not to question that? Wouldn't any country be foolish to ignore such a conflict of loyalties? Of course, you judge people by their actions, not their religion, but you can't insist on religion first loyalty and then act surprised when others see a problem with it.
 
Fair enough, but aren't you making the case for those who distrust Muslims yourself? If you're openly saying a Muslim's loyalty to his religious brotherhood comes before his own country, even when that brotherhood includes people across hostile borders, why would you expect his fellow countrymen not to question that? Wouldn't any country be foolish to ignore such a conflict of loyalties? Of course, you judge people by their actions, not their religion, but you can't insist on religion first loyalty and then act surprised when others see a problem with it.

You are just arguing without making a point. What on earth are you even trying to say?
 
You are just arguing without making a point. What on earth are you even trying to say?
My point is pretty simple. If your interpretation of Islam puts religious brotherhood above national loyalty, it might work in a Muslim majority country, but it creates an obvious conflict in a country where Muslims are a minority. That's the incompatibility I'm talking about.
 
Indian Muslims are Indians, not some overseas branch of Pakistan. We don't subscribe to this cross-border religious brotherhood nonsense. Keep your concerns within your own borders. Do we really care if Pakistan jails its leaders or lets its generals play king?
I know it isn't Pakistan's problem. I never said it was. I am giving you free advice.
 
Even if we assume this is a mainstream view, how exactly does it contradict anything I've said? You're confusing Hindu nationalism with putting religious loyalty above national loyalty. They're not the same thing.
So Indian hindus can be adherents of "hindu nationalism", but Indian muslims cannot be adherents of "Muslim nationalism"?

The above paradigm is unrelated to Pakistan, before you default to that gibberish.
 
Until today, I genuinely thought the "southies" were the smart bunch.
 
So Indian hindus can be adherents of "hindu nationalism", but Indian muslims cannot be adherents of "Muslim nationalism"?

The above paradigm is unrelated to Pakistan, before you default to that gibberish.
Who said Hindu nationalism gets a free pass? If it puts Hindu identity above Indian identity, I've got a problem with that too.

And what exactly do you mean by Muslim nationalism? Nationalism for Indian Muslims within India, or loyalty to a Muslim brotherhood stretching across the globe, above national borders? Because those are two very different things.

My point is simple, country before religion whether you're Hindu, Muslim or anything else.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top