Iran - Israel/US War: Israel-US declare war on Iran, Iran responds

If Israel has indeed destroyed 70% of Irans ability to manufacture steel, then what has Iran destroyed that is 70% of Israel capability?
Destroyed my ass. At best they have damaged some parts of these factories.
And Iran has hit Israeli factories and steel and aluminum factories throughout the region, particularly in Bahrain, Kuwait and the Emirates.
 
Israel is not holding back, and is focussed on destroying real capability. That is not the case with Iran.

I don't fully understand Iran's approach. It may be a limitation in their mosaic approach ? Lack of senior experienced leadership ? Lack of doctrine, or strategy ?

With the exception of taking out the radars across the middle east for which there is a strategy and goal, there is not a coherent approach to the targeting of other targets in Israel as if there is no real strategy? Difficult to say.

At this point, given what Israel has attacked, Iran should have by now destroyed all of Israel power generation and oil infrastructure targets, but it has at best made 1 or 2 hits and destroy a single power generation facility or oil storage or processing facility out of the many that Israel has. 1 or 2 "targeting", and then they seem to think that is it ??

Odd - they learnt some things from the 12day war, but there obviously needs more work to be done on military strategy and the idea of "completion of mission objectives". A lot lot more. ( That will be a thread in its own right once this war is done, ie all the flaws in Irans conduct of war ..).
I've said similar on here but one us jet out of the 1000 they own gets shot down and Iran is a brilliant combatant.

I've seen very little from Iran that's actually impactful on any military targets. The US bases they attack are basically empty apart from a few contractors, and that's pretty much all they've done. Most the missiles are landing in residential areas or open areas and damage is minimal, of course there will be a lot of injuries from these attacks but that's purely due to shrapnel causing damage.

They fire a dozen missiles on a good day, a few will get intercepted, a few will hit a field, one or two in a residential area and another hits the storage room of a semi abandoned US base.

Meanwhile Israel and the US have destroyed the leadership, lots of military and civilian targets, naval, air force etc.

Somehow Iran is painted as a winner? It's a big fucking nation of 100 million, if this is their show of defense/attack then it's fucking embarrassing, downed possibly a few planes which were asking for it by low flying and fired hundreds of missiles at pretty much nothing.

Closing down the straits isn't a genius move, Egypt has closed the Suez before and this is no different, requires very little manpower and mostly just threats which will stop pretty much anyone.
 
So it was off the coast and not in central Iran. That's why I believe Israel did something to bring it down.

Iranians couldn't get to the place to capture pilots nor seemed to be able to fire at this aircraft.

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
 
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.


To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
 
I've said similar on here but one us jet out of the 1000 they own gets shot down and Iran is a brilliant combatant.

I've seen very little from Iran that's actually impactful on any military targets. The US bases they attack are basically empty apart from a few contractors, and that's pretty much all they've done. Most the missiles are landing in residential areas or open areas and damage is minimal, of course there will be a lot of injuries from these attacks but that's purely due to shrapnel causing damage.

They fire a dozen missiles on a good day, a few will get intercepted, a few will hit a field, one or two in a residential area and another hits the storage room of a semi abandoned US base.

Meanwhile Israel and the US have destroyed the leadership, lots of military and civilian targets, naval, air force etc.

Somehow Iran is painted as a winner? It's a big fucking nation of 100 million, if this is their show of defense/attack then it's fucking embarrassing, downed possibly a few planes which were asking for it by low flying and fired hundreds of missiles at pretty much nothing.

Closing down the straits isn't a genius move, Egypt has closed the Suez before and this is no different, requires very little manpower and mostly just threats which will stop pretty much anyone.

I think once you stop watch just Fox News you will be really shocked at what has been going on in the real world.
 
So it was off the coast and not in central Iran. That's why I believe Israel did something to bring it down.

Iranians couldn't get to the place to capture pilots nor seemed to be able to fire at this aircraft.

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.


It Never was alleged it was central Iran. Originally it was Khuzestan province which is max 100KM from the border even assuming it was on the outer edges of the province.

Now some reports are saying it was closer to Kharg Island.
 
If Israel has indeed destroyed 70% of Irans ability to manufacture steel, then what has Iran destroyed that is 70% of Israel capability?


I would take this number with the same seriousness of their claims on taking out missile launchers.

More likely some level of damage was done to some steel plants.

Iran would by now almost certainly be purely focused on Zionist infrastructure targets if this was true.
 
I've said similar on here but one us jet out of the 1000 they own gets shot down and Iran is a brilliant combatant.

I've seen very little from Iran that's actually impactful on any military targets. The US bases they attack are basically empty apart from a few contractors, and that's pretty much all they've done. Most the missiles are landing in residential areas or open areas and damage is minimal, of course there will be a lot of injuries from these attacks but that's purely due to shrapnel causing damage.

They fire a dozen missiles on a good day, a few will get intercepted, a few will hit a field, one or two in a residential area and another hits the storage room of a semi abandoned US base.

Meanwhile Israel and the US have destroyed the leadership, lots of military and civilian targets, naval, air force etc.

Somehow Iran is painted as a winner? It's a big fucking nation of 100 million, if this is their show of defense/attack then it's fucking embarrassing, downed possibly a few planes which were asking for it by low flying and fired hundreds of missiles at pretty much nothing.

Closing down the straits isn't a genius move, Egypt has closed the Suez before and this is no different, requires very little manpower and mostly just threats which will stop pretty much anyone.
US modern fighting strategy is not 1990's or 2003 anymore. It's largely deploying aerial firepower. Iran has scored some hits on parked tankers or tankers in the air, other US aircraft across some of these US bases.

You cannot kill US soldiers because nobody knows where they are dispersed across the Middle East.

But yes they don't have a strong offensive conventional capability against US/Israel , but who (in the region) does ? Serious question for you.

Iran is surviving war with the US whom most nations will succumb to rather quickly. US isn't 'on time' like Trump keeps claiming. US is unable to achieve the political objectives it wants. Which is what war is about. Thus they are losing and Iran is winning, for now.
 
French likely paid Iran to get a ship through strait of Hormuz

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

Obviously they paid.
And it is very good. Not only revenues from oil also from this toll.
Surprisingly this should be one of the goals of the war. If Islamic Republic can keep this toll working, reconstruction will be easier and some relief to the suffered iranian population. So good luck with this new bussiness.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Pakistan Defence Latest

Country Watch Latest

Back
Top