Opinion Piece- Beyond Partition: Imagining an India-Pakistan Friendship

I think I understand your position. You've experienced the hostility of the last 14 years, believe ordinary Indians share responsibility for it, want that experience preserved in the national memory of future generations, see little benefit in bilateral relations, and consider an apology a prerequisite for any rapprochement.

But here's where I struggle with this reasoning.

I could make almost the exact same argument from the Indian side, and I suspect you could anticipate what that would look like. We have our own catalogue of grievances, casualties, attacks, humiliations and historical grievances. We can point to our own experiences, insist that Pakistanis acknowledge them, demand apologies and conclude that there is little to be gained from engaging with a country that has caused us so much grief.

And so what? We arrive at precisely where we are today, with each side's grievances serving as justification for the other's continued estrangement.

I also find your interpretation of my position rather curious. You seem to assume that my interest in exploring better relations stems from a belief that Pakistan is ascending, India is losing ground, and that this somehow creates an opportunity or incentive to seek friendship. I don't see the connection. My position would be exactly the same irrespective of which country was economically, militarily or geopolitically ascendant.

I'm not making a case for friendship because Pakistan needs something from India, or because India needs something from Pakistan. I'm questioning the value of perpetuating an adversarial relationship simply because both sides have convinced themselves that the other deserves nothing better.

The question I'm exploring is what this arrangement has cost us, what continuing it will cost us, and what an alternative might look like.

You have missed the difference, non state actors versus state terrorizing and killing the other country's population, or may be even their own to achieve a new norm. When did Pakistani state ever ordered to bomb a temple inside india?

I have nowhere suggested that Pakistan is in a better situation than india. All I know for sure is, Pakistan is better off without india. indian policy to isolate and hurt Pakistan has failed, but it has proven one thing for Pakistan, we do not need to engage with india, we are two different people, two different destinies. Enmity with india is better for Pakistan, it removes the confusion and keeps us clear.
 
I don't know what is the condition in Pakistan,

Few years ago I was hopeless and thought Pakistanis are going to be the worst uncivilized baboons. But somehow, do not know how, but the signs are there that Pakistani society is improving, they have started to care, they have started to act decent, they have started to show maturity.
 
Best you don't go down this route. The OP did not intend this thread as a Kashmir discussion.

Visit one of those more relevant threads, tag me and others. And we will certainly discuss the wishes of Kashmiris, along with the matters of Junagadh, Goa and Hyderabad. No need to tie yourself into a Gordian knot over here.
OP wants friendship first and Kashmir, Junagarh, Goa, Hyderabad after. Are you OK with that.

Did you forget Lakshadweep.
 
Kashmir issue is not over even if it is a 1000 year long fight.

Pakistan has not given up its claim on Kashmir.

End of discussion.

Yeah we can keep up the symbolic claim to make ourselves feel good but it's well and truly settled. Only thing left is to make the LoC and IB.
 
If I understand your position correctly and please correct me if I'm wrong:

- You're not opposed to reducing hostility or having more cordial relations with India.
- You don't necessarily want friendship or closer cultural ties.
- You see Islam as the principal distinguishing feature of Pakistani identity.
- You're concerned that greater cultural exchange, particularly given India's much larger entertainment industry, could dilute Pakistan's distinct cultural identity.
- You'd rather preserve that distinction, even if it means maintaining some degree of cultural separation.

I can understand the concern, but I disagree with the underlying assumption.

Surely a culture confident in its own identity should be able to engage with another without fearing its own dilution?

I don't see why peaceful coexistence, trade, tourism or even cultural exchange should come at the expense of Pakistani identity. Nor do I think Islam is the only thing that distinguishes Pakistan from India. There are distinct histories, languages, regional identities and cultural traditions that are worth preserving in their own right.

Why should being good neighbours require becoming culturally alike?


Precisely yes.

We can be good neighbors but I want zero cultural exchange.
 
@Krptonite

I have three questions for the OP on how to resolve these realities:

Security mutual trust is virtually non-existent.

Water disputes are escalating, which is far more sensitive than typical trade friction.

Domestic politics in both countries leave no room for concessions—any move toward de-escalation will be attacked by opponents as "weakness."
 
Last edited:
View attachment 223198

While the sentiments on this thread are genuine and worthy of documenting, the reality remains far removed from such thought experimentation.

I think that of the two nations, it is India that has officially chosen a path of "total war", encompassing kinetic, economic, political, and social hostility. Certainly, individual Indians may seek rapprochement and civil discourse but the hatred we observe towards our culture, our sportsmen, our businesses and citizens cannot be swept under the carpet. The civil (or "uncivil") backlash against ANY publicised attempt at cordial engagement is rabid and immediate. Why should Pakistanis overlook this? Indeed, for many years, Pakistan tried through official channels to remind Indians that separation of regional politics from civilian life was possible - to no avail.

I, for one, remain satisfied with Pakistan's approach towards India. It seems as though Modi bit off far more than he could chew when deciding to confront Pakistan directly and unashamedly. In fact, I feel our officials remain far too LENIENT towards such an incorrigible and hostile attitude.

Take sports, for example. If Hindustanis see fit to refuse to engage in sportsmanlike conduct when playing against Pakistanis, then kindly "do one" properly! India should unilaterally forfeit all sporting fixtures against Pakistan, as Iran does with Israel over similar ideological rationale, and take whatever consequences come (mostly financial) on the chin, in reverence to their ideological mantra. Of course, we all know the rupee is worth more than these falsified ideologies that are brandished by these fraudsters, so no principled boycott of Pakistan will be forthcoming. In this scenario, Pakistan should reject sporting interactions of any kind with any Indian team that refuses basic on-field civility.
@Krptonite
Couple of days ago - India juniors played Pakistan at cricket. India won. The response of the Indian kids was next level. They made gestures and swore at the mothers of the Pakistan players. Was a horrible watch. This anger seems to be next level and its rife.
Not suggesting Pak youth arent with guilt - some of their behavior too is unacceptable but the hatred coming and stemming from those in charge is propagating on dangerous levels.
There is far less animosity and hatred from those that are for example living in the UK by both parties - those that have been recently imported - wow - next level.
I don't think anyone should overlook or excuse the kind of behaviour being described here. The hostility is real, and the influence of political leadership in legitimising and propagating it cannot be understated. When young cricketers are displaying this sort of behaviour, it should concern us all.

But I wonder whether we're allowing the worst examples of our interactions to become the basis on which we judge the entirety of our relationship.

Posters describe describe India as having chosen a path of total hostility, and I understand the reasoning behind that assessment. But this posture has not evolved in isolation, We can make almost identical arguments from either side. If each society uses the other's conduct to justify its own continued hostility, we end up with two countries permanently validating each other's worst instincts.

Musings makes an interesting observation about Indians and Pakistanis living in the UK. Perhaps there's something worth examining there. The political and national baggage doesn't necessarily disappear, but the environment in which people interact changes. They encounter one another as colleagues, neighbours, friends and acquaintances rather than exclusively as Indians and Pakistanis. And perhaps that makes it easier to see one another as individuals.

I keep coming back to this very thread. Look at the people participating. We disagree, occasionally provoke one another, push each other's buttons and bring plenty of baggage into the conversation. Yet, outside those moments, we are perfectly capable of having a straightforward exchange. We can explain ourselves, listen, challenge opinions and sometimes even find common ground.

Does that count for nothing?

I do think we sometimes conflate the people who have hurt us with the people we have yet to meet. The two aren't necessarily the same.

And perhaps that's where I differ. I don't believe friendship has to be the reward for resolving every disagreement, nor do I believe that the accumulated bitterness between our countries makes it impossible. Recognition, familiarity and the desire to connect are human instincts too. They don't disappear simply because we have a difficult history.

We have become rather like two hedgehogs, approaching each other with our spines raised, each anticipating the other's hostility and inevitably adding to it. At some point, surely, it is worth asking whether we can do something differently.
 
You have missed the difference, non state actors versus state terrorizing and killing the other country's population, or may be even their own to achieve a new norm. When did Pakistani state ever ordered to bomb a temple inside india?

I have nowhere suggested that Pakistan is in a better situation than india. All I know for sure is, Pakistan is better off without india. indian policy to isolate and hurt Pakistan has failed, but it has proven one thing for Pakistan, we do not need to engage with india, we are two different people, two different destinies. Enmity with india is better for Pakistan, it removes the confusion and keeps us clear.
I actually understand where you're coming from. Pakistan has managed without India, has other partners and avenues to pursue, and given the history between the two countries, I can understand why you see little incentive to engage with a neighbour you consider hostile. I'm not suggesting that this is an unreasonable position.

Where I differ is in what I consider the larger objective.

Both our countries have enormous populations relative to the resources available to develop them. Poverty remains high, human development has a long way to go, and the challenge of lifting hundreds of millions of people into prosperity is going to occupy us for generations. When I look at the next 50 years, I find it difficult to justify ruling out entire avenues of opportunity without at least examining what they might offer.

And this isn't necessarily about India being the answer to Pakistan's problems, or Pakistan being the answer to India's. It's about being willing to consider every reasonable possibility, even those that might seem unpalatable today.

Ultimately, I keep coming back to Abdul and Ram. If I have to make a choice between exploring opportunities that might help Abdul and Ram become economically independent, provide better lives for their families and give their children a better future, versus allowing their prospects to remain constrained because we cannot get past our mutual animosity, then I think I owe it to them to examine that choice honestly.

I'm not suggesting we disregard security, abandon our interests or place blind faith in a neighbour. Nor am I saying friendship must come at any cost.

But surely our ambition should be more than simply demonstrating that we can manage without one another?
 
@Krptonite

I have three questions for the OP on how to resolve these realities:

Security mutual trust is virtually non-existent.

Water disputes are escalating, which is far more sensitive than typical trade friction.

Domestic politics in both countries leave no room for concessions—any move toward de-escalation will be attacked by opponents as "weakness."
Hero, I think these are probably the three biggest obstacles, and I'll be honest, I don't have easy answers to any of them, but i am willing to explore with you what the answer could be

On security, I can understand why mutual trust is virtually non-existent. Both countries have accumulated enough history to be deeply suspicious of the other's intentions.

On water, I think the concern is even more fundamental. If agreements that have governed the relationship for decades can be set aside, then it's perfectly understandable to ask what assurances or guarantees remain. This isn't some ordinary bilateral disagreement. It affects livelihoods and the lives of millions. I wouldn't expect Pakistanis to simply brush that concern aside.

And domestic politics? I agree. The political environment in both countries makes any gesture towards engagement vulnerable to being portrayed as weakness or betrayal.

But here's where I think we might differ. Do these realities mean that we accept the relationship as it stands indefinitely, or do we at least retain the ambition to change it?

I don't have a blueprint for how we get there. I don't even think we're in a position to have some grand conversation about friendship today. But I do think we need to leave room for the possibility that circumstances can change, that trust can eventually be rebuilt, and that future generations might approach these questions differently.

My concern is that if we allow today's political realities and grievances to become permanent assumptions about what is possible, we risk making them a self-fulfilling prophecy.

I suppose I'm less interested in pretending the obstacles aren't there, and more interested in refusing to accept that they must define the next fifty years as well.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Pakistan Defence Latest

Country Watch Latest

Back
Top