Opinion Piece- Beyond Partition: Imagining an India-Pakistan Friendship

Onto the next segment for why I believe friendship is not impossible
I'd like to pull the thread on the points @HERO mentions starting with Security and mutual trust

I'd start by looking at it from an Indian perspective where the friction actually originates and what could be an alternative response to the historical response

Take a major terrorist attack in India. People are killed, public anger understandably follows, and there is pressure on the government to demonstrate that such attacks will carry consequences. If the investigation points towards organisations operating from Pakistan, the issue quickly becomes an interstate one. India faces pressure to respond punitively, and military action becomes one possible means of demonstrating resolve.

Pakistan then faces its own pressures. A strike on its territory, particularly one resulting in casualties, cannot easily go unanswered. Questions of sovereignty, deterrence and national credibility come into play. Pakistan responds, India faces pressure to respond again, and what began as a terrorist incident can quickly become a military confrontation between two nuclear-armed countries.

The reverse dynamic exists as well. Pakistan has its own security grievances, and Indian actions that Pakistan perceives as hostile can generate similar pressures to respond. I'm not suggesting that the circumstances or responsibilities are necessarily equivalent in every incident, but the cycle of escalation is familiar.

So how do we interrupt it?

I think there are a few things worth exploring.

First, an agreed crisis protocol. A serious terrorist or cross-border security incident should trigger direct communication between designated security and military officials, an exchange of available information and an effort to establish the facts before either side takes action that could trigger a wider confrontation.

Second, a credible mechanism for establishing responsibility. India cannot reasonably be expected to accept a Pakistani denial as sufficient, just as Pakistan cannot be expected to accept an Indian accusation as sufficient justification for military action. Could both countries agree to an independent investigative mechanism for particularly serious incidents, involving forensic evidence, intelligence shared through secure channels and mutually accepted third-party expertise?

Third, there needs to be a credible route to accountability that doesn't automatically involve military action. If an investigation establishes that an organisation operating from Pakistani territory was responsible for an attack in India, there must be meaningful consequences: arrests, prosecutions and verifiable action against those responsible. Equally, serious security grievances raised by Pakistan should have a process through which they can be investigated and addressed.

I appreciate that none of this is straightforward. India may see such a process as allowing Pakistan to delay accountability, while Pakistan may see it as giving India a mechanism to legitimise accusations and exert pressure. Neither government will want to be seen as having its hands tied.

But perhaps that is precisely the point. Neither country needs to trust the other unconditionally. What we need are arrangements that can function even in the absence of trust, and that give both governments a way to respond to security incidents without immediately reaching for military options.

The question, then, is whether we can agree that a terrorist attack or security incident should trigger a process of investigation and accountability rather than an almost automatic march towards military escalation.
 
Fair point on human progress.

But landing on the moon was an engineering challenge—solve the physics, write the code, and you're there.

India-Pakistan reconciliation is a political, historical, and emotional challenge. It requires both sides to make concessions, and in both countries, any concession is politically costly at home.

These two kinds of "impossible" are fundamentally different in nature.
You've actually cornered me at the weakest point of my rebuttal

Maybe equating technological progress with social progress wasn’t exactly a smart choice but i would still stand behind the principle of it

You correctly identify the domain but the underlying potential for achieving impossible things be it social, technological or behavioural still applies

Things change, and if that is always going to be true then we must begin a dialogue about what positive change should look like
 
Even Kim Jong Un can acknowledge South Korea as an independent state and recognize the border between the two Koreas. So, nothing is impossible!

Between India and Pakistan, who will take the first step???
Kim always wanted to unite Koreans. Do you think Indians and Pakistanis wants to unite? It's a wrong comparison Koreans are basically same people who got split over political differences, India Pakistan split due to religious problems. Those run deep.
It's more than just who will take first step at reapproachment it's more about how will this reapproachment be different from tens of other reapproachment that failed since 47. Which is why India and Pakistan decided to drop everything and just go be with themselves.
 
Fair point, better men than I have tried and failed

But tis a thought experiment @El Sidd , the implication that a forum thread will lead to peace between our nations is laughably absurd

All tis wretched existence allows, is to connect with those on the other side of the aisle, and that is sufficient

Waste your time alone maybe?

It's like that Indian who reported on the thread that Indians have moved on and have no benefits with any interaction with Pakistan and Pakistanis and yet continue to be an active Indian member on Pakistani section of this international forum.

The relations are going to get much worse on people to people scale as an inevitable total war beckons for both the countries.
 
@Krptonite
Couple of days ago - India juniors played Pakistan at cricket. India won. The response of the Indian kids was next level. They made gestures and swore at the mothers of the Pakistan players. Was a horrible watch. This anger seems to be next level and its rife.
Not suggesting Pak youth arent with guilt - some of their behavior too is unacceptable but the hatred coming and stemming from those in charge is propagating on dangerous levels.
There is far less animosity and hatred from those that are for example living in the UK by both parties - those that have been recently imported - wow - next level.
Correct, Sir.

Even on Indian forums like Bharat Rakshak, Indians openly wish for the destruction of Pakistan, insult Islam, or Muslims.

Then on Pakistani forums, or channels, when Pakistanis do the same to Indians, Indian cry foul on our forums, calling it racist or discriminatory.
 
It took indians, how many, 14 years to realise and then want to normalize the situation?

What are the guarantees, indians won't choose another extremist hindu for next 14 years and believe him wholeheartedly and follow him blindly?

In these 14 years, india has spent each and every ounce of its energy to defame Pakistan, try and spread propaganda against its people, try to isolate it, boycott it and even attacked Pakistan and its citizens twice or if you believe in that surgical strike chooran, then three times.

Are you going to apologize first as a nation? Before we talk about normalcy?

I hope, no Pakistani forgets those more than two decades of terrorism, bomb blasts, attacks and killing. I want these years to be included in our syllabus and become part of our history lectures and each and every Pakistani child taught about how a coward enemy tried to kill us for being Pakistani.
This is self-serving tripe. It takes some cheek to ask an enemy for an apology as if it were a one-sided affair. While Pakistan asks for apologies, India has been asking for one for decades. Where does the list of grievances India needs apologies for begin and end?

Khalistan? Kargil? Definitely Kashmir? Always liked how Pakistan would say they supported the insurgents politically and diplomatically, but not militarily, which everybody knew was a lie. The forcing out of the Pandits was an act of genocide. And what about the various acts of terrorism, the most memorable being the 26/11 Mumbai attacks?

Still awaiting apologies for all.

As for who India votes for, frankly, it's none of your business. India isn't concerned about who Pakistan's PM is because the behavior will be the same. In fact, Modi was a response to the events I listed above.
 
There is & never will be peace between the two nation, What i would say we can be respected/honorable enemies, which itself is too much to ask from Indians these days. The mindset of Indians not the politicians or policy makers but the everday Indians is the biggest hurdle between Peace. Indians consider themselves superior, consider Pakistan to be some kind of unfinished business or cutaway piece of their Akhlund Bharat, this is also ecoed by Indian media, Analysts, and think tanks, When Modi came to power things took a downward spiral, it didn't happen just because Modi was now in Power, every Indian knows Modi's background and his role in Gujrat riots, and yet even the "Liberal" & "Nuetral" Indians flock to Modi/BJP in their attempts to isolate Pakistan, shame Pakistan and blame Pakistan for every ills in their country.

There is also a religious angle here, rising thook Jihad, cow killings, property jihad and love jihad, none of it actually exists in Islam and if educated Indians don't know that then they are even dumber than i thought but if they know it and still go along with it (which i believe it is) then their hate for Islam/Muslims is out in the open, You can compare that with Trump's election of 2016. Trump used careful speech with right wing and Fascist, but as soon as he get into power white power, proud boys and other right wing racists feel embolden, that part of the society came out of shadows to openly show their hate and disgust for Minorities, same thing happen in Modi's India, India was always like that regardless of what they pretend to show a more secular image, modi only took the veil off from that ugly Indian society.

Now, how will anyone from Pakistan even think or entertain the idea of peace with India? remember BLA spokesperson were giving interviews on Indian media when 200 passengers were held Hostage by BLA and they were executing them? do people forget several Indian consultates in Afghanistan during Ghani/Karzai Govt which were basically hubs for Providing intel/weapons/money to TTP/BLA against Pakistani civilians? did Pakistani's forget how Indians ran the whole Campaign against Pakistan for supporting Afghan Taliban to isolate Pakistan, when Pakistan even at that time was the most affected country by terrorism, its like we were losing innocent civilians and yet we were to be blamed, no where in the world where a country who lost 10, 20, or 30 innocent people in mosques or Market, will be blamed for that attack. Not to mentioned the social media recorded Indian celebration of Pakistani dead children, women in terror related incidents, or even natural disaster or traffic related incidents. To this day, Indians haven't even acknowledge death of 30-40 civilians which include Children who's pictures are available, to them everyone they killed in their Operation Sindoor was a Terrorists, so anyone who even have a iota of shame left should go back and look at the pics of the dead kids.

And to those delulu Indians who think that there is a possibility of Peace, I doubt it... Indians have tasted the blood, they will continue to support BLA/TTP via Afghanistan, and now Afghan Taliban are sucking Indian Pickle and claims to have same DNA, RAW now have unlimited supply of disposable toilet paper aka fighters to continue this insurgency in Pakistan's 2 states. A destabilize Pakistan suits India, because they have their own short-comings when it comes to militarily defeating Pakistan, so they will continue to support terrorists inside Pakistan to keep PA/PN/PAF engage on that part of border.

I am sorry to burst anyone's bubble but there won't be any peace between the 2 countries, even if in next election Congress wins by majority, and they reopen the dialog Indians have to cut support for BLA/TTP which they won't, India also have a deep state / establishment which holds power regardless, yes maybe some people to people ties or artists may start going back and forth but neither country will stop finding ways to hurt the other. As far as issue like Kashmir is concern, its a dead horse both countries will keep beating, Pakistan can not take back rest of Kashmir with force, neither can India take AJK when both nations have roughly 200 nuclear bombs each, and heavy conventional militaries. Maybe some trade is possible but with that come spy networks and sabotages, there is no trust neither will that trust ever be build.

I am okay with the current status quo which is set, but like I said as Pakistani's would expect a honorable enemy, who will fight properly rather than using proxies like BLA/TTP who butcher Pakistani civilians, and keep Pakistan's economy weakened. Pakistan's support to Kashmiri fighters is pretty much dead, maybe some here and there but nothing significant, except it exists in Indian media, and public minds.
 
Last edited:
This is self-serving tripe. It takes some cheek to ask an enemy for an apology as if it were a one-sided affair. While Pakistan asks for apologies, India has been asking for one for decades. Where does the list of grievances India needs apologies for begin and end?

Khalistan? Kargil? Definitely Kashmir? Always liked how Pakistan would say they supported the insurgents politically and diplomatically, but not militarily, which everybody knew was a lie. The forcing out of the Pandits was an act of genocide. And what about the various acts of terrorism, the most memorable being the 26/11 Mumbai attacks?

Still awaiting apologies for all.

As for who India votes for, frankly, it's none of your business. India isn't concerned about who Pakistan's PM is because the behavior will be the same. In fact, Modi was a response to the events I listed above.
Yes. Invading sovereign East Pakistan and splitting it off from West Pakistan through simple acts of terrorism is clearly well beyond the scope of this "apologies" conversation.

You people get funnier and funnier every time you cry "victim saar!". Please organise some stand up shows about this topic.
 
There is & never will be peace between the two nation, What i would say we can be respected/honorable enemies, which itself is too much to ask from Indians these days. The mindset of Indians not the politicians or policy makers but the everday Indians is the biggest hurdle between Peace. Indians consider themselves superior, consider Pakistan to be some kind of unfinished business or cutaway piece of their Akhlund Bharat, this is also ecoed by Indian media, Analysts, and think tanks, When Modi came to power things took a downward spiral, it didn't happen just because Modi was now in Power, every Indian knows Modi's background and his role in Gujrat riots, and yet even the "Liberal" & "Nuetral" Indians flock to Modi/BJP in their attempts to isolate Pakistan, shame Pakistan and blame Pakistan for every ills in their country.

There is also a religious angle here, rising thook Jihad, cow killings, property jihad and love jihad, none of it actually exists in Islam and if educated Indians don't know that then they are even dumber than i thought but if they know it and still go along with it (which i believe it is) then their hate for Islam/Muslims is out in the open, You can compare that with Trump's election of 2016. Trump used careful speech with right wing and Fascist, but as soon as he get into power white power, proud boys and other right wing racists feel embolden, that part of the society came out of shadows to openly decade their hate and disgust for Minorities, same thing happen in Modi's India, India was always like that regardless of what they pretend to show a more secular image, modi only took the veil off from that ugly Indian society.

Now, how will anyone from Pakistan even think or entertain the idea of peace with India? remember BLA spokesperson were giving interview when 200 passengers were held Hostage by BLA and they were executing them? do people forget several Indian consultates in Afghanistan during Ghani/Karzai Govt which were basically hubs for Providing intel/weapons/money to TTP/BLA against Pakistani civilians? did Pakistani's forget how Indians ran the whole Campaign against Pakistan for supporting Afghan Taliban to isolate Pakistan, when Pakistan even at that time was the most affected country by terrorism, its like we were losing innocent civilians and yet we were to be blamed, no where in the world where a country who lost 10, 20, or 30 innocent people in mosques or Market, will be blamed for that attack. Not to mentioned the social media recorded Indian celebration of Pakistani dead children, women in terror related incidents, or even natural disaster or traffic related incidents. To this day, Indians haven't even acknowledge death of 30-40 civilians which include Children who's pictures are available, to them everyone they killed in their Operation Sindoor was a Terrorists, so anyone who even have a iota of shame left should go back and look at the pics of the dead kids.

And to those delulu Indians who think that there is a possibility of Peace, I doubt it... Indians have tasted the blood, they will continue to support BLA/TTP via Afghanistan, and now Afghan Taliban are sucking Indian Pickle and claims to have same DNA, RAW now have unlimited supply of disposable toilet paper aka fighters to continue this insurgency in Pakistan's 2 states. A destabilize Pakistan suits India, because they have their own short-comings when it comes to militarily defeating Pakistan, so they will continue to support terrorists inside Pakistan to keep PA/PN/PAF engage on that part of border.

I am sorry to burst anyone's bubble but there won't be any peace between the 2 countries, even if in next election Congress wins by majority, and they reopen the dialog Indians have to cut support for BLA/TTP which they won't, India also have a deep state / establishment which holds power regardless, yes maybe some people to people ties or artists may start going back and forth but neither country will stop finding ways to hurt the other. As far as issue like Kashmir is concern, its a dead horse both countries will keep beating, Pakistan can not take back rest of Kashmir with force, neither can India take AJK when both nations have roughly 200 nuclear bombs each, and heavy conventional militaries. Maybe some trade is possible but with that come spy networks and sabotages, there is no trust neither will that trust ever be build.

I am okay with the current status quo which is set, but like I said as Pakistani's would expect a honorable enemy, who will fight properly rather than using proxies like BLA/TTP who butcher Pakistani civilians, and keep Pakistan's economy weakened. Pakistan's support to Kashmiri fighters is pretty much dead, maybe some here and there but nothing significant, except it exists in Indian media, and public minds.
I too am okay with the current status quo, with the caveat that we should now be even more aggressive on the social/sports/cultural front.

Indeed, I would posit that the Modi administration probably didn't expect Pakistan to still exist today when Op Sindoor was launched. The plan was to overwhelm us militarily, activate Kabulites in the west, and simply dismantle our nation.

That we are still here and they no longer feel confident about even a 1 front war tells you all you need to know about WHY such conversations about "how to live with Pakistan as a neighbour" even exist.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Pakistan Defence Latest

Country Watch Latest

Back
Top