One of us Actually lives in the country.... can you guess who ?One of us read actual news out of your country and the other doesn’t. We will let the other members decide who is out of touch with reality.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
One of us Actually lives in the country.... can you guess who ?One of us read actual news out of your country and the other doesn’t. We will let the other members decide who is out of touch with reality.
One of us Actually lives in the country.... can you guess who ?
One of us Actually lives in the country.... can you guess who ?
Saudi Arabia got involved in Yemens internal conflict in 2015 and has been at war with the Houthis ever since.Because those are internal issues that started well before any pact and more importantly do not involve ANY external forces.
Balochistan has Baloch rebels which have shelter in areas but are essentially Pakistani.
KP has TTP who are considered Pakistani militants even if today the Afghan Taliban and them are pretty much the same.
Then Pakistan has to formally request help in that matter and ask for activation of any pacts and it never has.
So - great on the whataboutism - but it is apples and oranges.
Pakistan is the only country that broke TTP control over its mountain strongholds, something US and its dozen allies failed to do in Afghanistan after 20 years.
Its not really fair to compare the hamstrung and manipulated (by the Fauj) PTI coalition that barely governed for 3 years, to an entity that has essentially controlled the levers of power in Pakistan throughout its history.My generals would do the exact same as what my politicians have done, including Imran Khan, so let's not kid ourselves with this grandstanding.
and how is this relevant to the gibberish you said before ?If that meant anything, you would know that your army generals have always sucked up to Arab despots by acting as their mercenaries against poor Arabs. Just Google Black September and your army’s massacre of Palestinians in Jordan.
it does, someone living inside a house knows it better then someone who heard about it from somewhere.That has no bearing on anything for a "discussion forum".
Lived experiences are absolutely useful and offer insight, but as a debate tool they are better utilized as secondary support for a broader argument.it does, someone living inside a house knows it better then someone who heard about it from somewhere.
and how is this relevant to the gibberish you said before ?
I did , he never responded,Lived experiences are absolutely useful and offer insight, but as a debate tool they are better utilized as secondary support for a broader argument.
Your lived experience in any region only offers a window into YOUR specific experiences and interactions and cannot possibly account for all the variables and complexities playing out in a diverse society, let alone in a conflict zone.
The poster you responded to made a claim - a better approach, if you disagree, would be to ask them to substantiate said claim, rather than dismissing them by claiming lived experience.
Not the first time he's resorted to this "I live here you don't".That has no bearing on anything for a "discussion forum".
Since you used the word "apologists", let me be clear, I don't justify Fauji overthrow etc. (I have never said here that I am happy with the prevailing situation) nor do I justify IK's incarceration and believe he should be freed.Its not really fair to compare the hamstrung and manipulated (by the Fauj) PTI coalition that barely governed for 3 years, to an entity that has essentially controlled the levers of power in Pakistan throughout its history.
In fact, one of the more popular arguments used by Fauji apologists (to justify the overthrow of the PTI government), is that IK ‘refused to listen to the Fauji leadership about Russia and Palestine’. IK also fell out if favor for pursuing an Islamic bloc free of the control of the psychopath running Saudi Arabia … sounds like IK would have done exactly what the Fauji leadership refuses to do.
Fair - my apologies for implying you’re an apologist for the Fauj.Since you used the word "apologists", let me be clear, I don't justify Fauji overthrow etc. (I have never said here that I am happy with the prevailing situation) nor do I justify IK's incarceration and believe he should be freed.