Pakistan's New Provinces Plan ?

True the provisional governments and MNAs MPAs will not share power but the exact same will happen if Pakistan had 30 provinces, with 30 CMs, Cabinets, assemblies. They will do exact same and will loot. I think this move will lead to more issues and hatred, it's best to turn districts in to local empowered governments.
Exactly! Thus, I really don't see any point in having "more" administrative units with REAL power & control lying somewhere else:
What's even the point of having "more" administrative units when the REAL power still remains within the military establishment? 🙄
 
Exactly! Thus, I really don't see any point in having "more" administrative units with REAL power & control lying somewhere else:
But they dont have real control or more provinces will not be needed. They only get involved at the highest level if security situation arises or anything serious, it is the local dacoits in charge who loot, these same dacoits then refuse to share power ie devolve power. In AJK once we had this honest police officer lady, she was AC level and she worked hard to implement law, refused to listen to the corrupt MNAs but the local people were not happy with her, she stopped them when they misused the law and overtook government land, after a few years locals and MNAs jointly character assassinated her, accusing her of disgusting things and she then left her job, now they have replacement who takes under the table deals and everyone is happy. So we at times need to point fingers at the awaam aswell who are the most corrupt, only the good people, weak and poor suffer.
 
True the provisional governments and MNAs MPAs will not share power but the exact same will happen if Pakistan had 30 provinces, with 30 CMs, Cabinets, assemblies. They will do exact same and will loot. I think this move will lead to more issues and hatred, its best to turn districts in to local empowered governments. Or special economiz zones as suggested by one member.
The smaller they are, the more devolved the representation. This is akin to local bodies with the idea that people who live in the areas get to govern themselves. The bigger the province the more diluted the representation. Case in point, Sind. Karachi, the largest revenue-generating city in the entire county has no say in how it is run, managed, financed. Someone sitting in the CM house decides what monies go where.

As I stated earlier, in the case of Sind at least, had PPP allowed LBs to operate effectively, it would have headed off this new province plan altogether. PPP shot themselves in the foot due to sheer corruption and petty ethnic politics. They lost sight of what a developed Karachi could have done to their popularity.

What makes it worse is that Karachi also tends to boast the most educated population, per capita, so the critique of PPP is real, it stings and cannot be ignored indefinitely despite the tough skin of the shameless politicians who rule the city. Other provinces may have similar gripes about the lack of good governance, but Karachi's problems are acute. Anyone who lives, visits can attest to this.
 
Last edited:
Cannot be said better. 💯
What's even the point of having "more" administrative units when the REAL power still remains within the military establishment? 🙄
Unfortunately, the system is infected with micromanaging syndrome. Until they empower local bodies i.e District, Tehsil/Taluka and UCs, no provinces would help.

I bet you South Punjab province will become an interior Sindh 2.0. a feudal fiefdom
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Pakistan Defence Latest

Country Watch Latest

Back
Top