Towards a Pakistani Islamic Renaissance: Reconstructing the State, Reviving Civilization, and Developing the Individual

The essence of politics lies in the art of balancing the governance of a group.

The fundamental "schism", if you call it that, is on the right to rule...
Governance and the governed.
Should it be hereditary, or sampled from the best among.
It quickly transitioned into hereditary, where the powerful wrested the seat from the rest.

It isn't, and never was a populist outcry, where +1 gives you all. And many never saw the path clearly, it expanded too fast and too far... it had to... but the consolidation never came... so the periphery collapsed. But, Islam gave agency and free market... it never was communist, nor capitalist. Free market rule the pricing till the markets balanced themselves. It disavowed usury, or time based compensation, which makes those under the thumb slaves by proxy. So, your profit or loss depended on invisible hand of the market and the governed were to be ensured of that by the prevailing regime.
The agency of the people; as the tribes and languages ...

Surah Al-Hujurat (Verse 13)
"O humanity! Indeed, We created you from a male and a female, and made you into peoples and tribes so that you may ˹get to˺ know one another. Surely the most noble of you in the sight of Allah is the most righteous among you. Allah is truly All-Knowing, All-Aware."

The free will, lineage and languages are protected giving them agency as equals in matters of decision-making. The "shura" or consultative body, represented by one of their for their own... where each sends their emissary and not proxy populist shyster for own cause(s)... in a true house of Representatives.

So, Yes. It is political in that unlike Christian theological interpretation "give unto Caesar..." Islam retains its constitution as foundational to the governance.
 
Wond

Wonders of AI ....it can turn caw of the crow into Mozart's fifth symphony
yes, I use Ai to clean up the raw language and formalize it. Can you read it? Do you understand it? Can you critically understand what you're reading - and try to counter-balance my views without retorting to tantrum on every post of mine?
 
Islamic economic system is a balance between the extremes of Capitalism and Communism. In today's World, it is near to the social benefits system of Norway and Sweden which is the best in the World.
 
The fundamental "schism", if you call it that, is on the right to rule...
Governance and the governed.
Should it be hereditary, or sampled from the best among.
It quickly transitioned into hereditary, where the powerful wrested the seat from the rest.

It isn't, and never was a populist outcry, where +1 gives you all. And many never saw the path clearly, it expanded too fast and too far... it had to... but the consolidation never came... so the periphery collapsed. But, Islam gave agency and free market... it never was communist, nor capitalist. Free market rule the pricing till the markets balanced themselves. It disavowed usury, or time based compensation, which makes those under the thumb slaves by proxy. So, your profit or loss depended on invisible hand of the market and the governed were to be ensured of that by the prevailing regime.
The agency of the people; as the tribes and languages ...

Surah Al-Hujurat (Verse 13)
"O humanity! Indeed, We created you from a male and a female, and made you into peoples and tribes so that you may ˹get to˺ know one another. Surely the most noble of you in the sight of Allah is the most righteous among you. Allah is truly All-Knowing, All-Aware."

The free will, lineage and languages are protected giving them agency as equals in matters of decision-making. The "shura" or consultative body, represented by one of their for their own... where each sends their emissary and not proxy populist shyster for own cause(s)... in a true house of Representatives.

So, Yes. It is political in that unlike Christian theological interpretation "give unto Caesar..." Islam retains its constitution as foundational to the governance.
To begin with, I have already stated that I am an atheist. I have no interest in the tenets of Islam, nor do I hold any position—whether of questioning, criticizing, or endorsing—regarding them. Of course, for research purposes, I will try to read some materials. But the direction of my reading and analysis is definitely completely different from that of Muslims.

Furthermore, I am aware that Islam is a system in which religion and state are integrated—a point to which I have no objection. My primary focus of study is the integration and friction between the Islamic world and the non-Islamic world, as well as the issues arising between Muslim and non-Muslim communities. As for the internal dynamics among various groups within Islam, that is a matter for the Muslim community itself. ------ Within the Islamic world, there exist many different sects. There is also considerable debate among these groups regarding the interpretation of the Quran and Islamic law. Perhaps you could take a closer look at how many internal wars have actually occurred in the Islamic world? ------ So, is the version of Islamic law that you subscribe to consistent with how it is understood by other sects or in other Islamic nations? You might want to start by reflecting on this question.

The essence of politics lies in the art of balancing the governance of a group.

Whether or not you agree with this statement, it is a reality in the real world. No matter how strictly one adheres to Islamic law, in the real world, every Islamic nation makes compromises—to varying degrees—with the realities of the world. Naturally, this is also true for China. Driven by practical needs and pressures, we, too, are often compelled to make compromises. Such is the nature of realpolitik.

Take note: in Pakistan, it is still possible to purchase alcohol. We are fully aware that some Muslims in Pakistan drink alcohol and are not held accountable. In China, there are very strict prohibitions on firearms, yet some citizens are still legally permitted to own guns.
This is reality—the art of political compromise.

If the revival of Pakistan is built entirely upon—and confined within—the Islamic world, then there is no issue whatsoever. You are free to continue adhering 100% to the tenets and laws of the Islamic faith; we have no objection to that.

However, if you wish to engage with the non-Islamic world—or if you seek to attract more investors into the Islamic world—you will inevitably encounter a clash of perspectives between the Islamic and non-Islamic spheres.

In such a scenario, the question we must consider is that of mutual compromise. This cannot be a one-sided endeavor; it must be reciprocal. If you insist on a stance of absolute, one-sided non-compromise, then conflict will inevitably follow.

Of course, you could use a more pleasant term or a different approach to dress up the concept of "compromise." But that is beside the point; its essence remains unchanged.
 
To begin with, I have already stated that I am an atheist. I have no interest in the tenets of Islam, nor do I hold any position—whether of questioning, criticizing, or endorsing—regarding them. Of course, for research purposes, I will try to read some materials. But the direction of my reading and analysis is definitely completely different from that of Muslims.

I get it... it is purely academic. And no one is forcing your discourse.

Furthermore, I am aware that Islam is a system in which religion and state are integrated—a point to which I have no objection. My primary focus of study is the integration and friction between the Islamic world and the non-Islamic world, as well as the issues arising between Muslim and non-Muslim communities.

Muslims are to adhere to the tenets of their faith regardless of the setting and maintain relations with the larger communities. Move, as a last resort, if oppressed.
The cumulative of consequences of ones actions and logical conclusion will pave the way forward and be the ultimate answer on best practices.

As the carnal instinct and innate nature doesn't question the foundational morality and principles it is rested upon.


As for the internal dynamics among various groups within Islam, that is a matter for the Muslim community itself. ------ Within the Islamic world, there exist many different sects. There is also considerable debate among these groups regarding the interpretation of the Quran and Islamic law. Perhaps you could take a closer look at how many internal wars have actually occurred in the Islamic world?
Unless that war or internal strife was purely theological... you'll find multiple reasons principally, power and politics. The majority schools of Islam followed today were formed outside the purview and confines of the states... meaning outside the corridors of power and some were even persecuted for their stances by the then regimes.
The four Ahl-Sunnah in Maliki, Shafi'i, Hanbali and Hanafi and their distribution is geographical primarily. As to the Shi'i the primary Isna Ashari adhered to a quiet school till their Imam, or leader, came... that only changed in Iran recently by a theological change in that doctrine and brought about the Vilayat Faqih. The talfiri schools of recent history only founded states very recently and they now claim a larger bandwidth as well.

So that premise is very subjective.


------ So, is the version of Islamic law that you subscribe to consistent with how it is understood by other sects or in other Islamic nations? You might want to start by reflecting on this question.

The essence of politics lies in the art of balancing the governance of a group.
The question of state and governance hasn't really been a theological discourse historically even amongst sects because they were themselves persecuted by the state for it's political survival. The recent vectors in both takfiri and Shi'i ideology have founded states and they of course have enshrined their power in theology but their is no larger consensus on it. Instead, many have resorted to western nation state model.



Whether or not you agree with this statement, it is a reality in the real world. No matter how strictly one adheres to Islamic law, in the real world, every Islamic nation makes compromises—to varying degrees—with the realities of the world. Naturally, this is also true for China. Driven by practical needs and pressures, we, too, are often compelled to make compromises. Such is the nature of realpolitik.
Correct.

Take note: in Pakistan, it is still possible to purchase alcohol. We are fully aware that some Muslims in Pakistan drink alcohol and are not held accountable. In China, there are very strict prohibitions on firearms, yet some citizens are still legally permitted to own guns.
This is reality—the art of political compromise.
However there is no theological debate on such... ones who delve know it and engage for notoriety and outlaw/above the law aura farming.


If the revival of Pakistan is built entirely upon—and confined within—the Islamic world, then there is no issue whatsoever. You are free to continue adhering 100% to the tenets and laws of the Islamic faith; we have no objection to that.

However, if you wish to engage with the non-Islamic world—or if you seek to attract more investors into the Islamic world—you will inevitably encounter a clash of perspectives between the Islamic and non-Islamic spheres.

Not necessarily, political discourse and engagement on trade has bearing on it's dealings and merits, not perspectives of the wider world.


In such a scenario, the question we must consider is that of mutual compromise. This cannot be a one-sided endeavor; it must be reciprocal. If you insist on a stance of absolute, one-sided non-compromise, then conflict will inevitably follow.
Again there is no inherent conflict and there is no reason to find one. The theological debate or setting of morality and systemic change has an open audience and no expiration date set...

Of course, you could use a more pleasant term or a different approach to dress up the concept of "compromise." But that is beside the point; its essence remains unchanged.

That Compromise is never foundational.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Pakistan Defence Latest

Country Watch Latest

Back
Top