Towards a Pakistani Islamic Renaissance: Reconstructing the State, Reviving Civilization, and Developing the Individual

I think you might have misunderstood this issue—or perhaps I didn’t express myself clearly enough.

Let me put this more bluntly (and please accept my apologies in advance, as the nature of this discussion—compounded by the complexities of translation—may touch upon sensitive or taboo subjects).

Islamic doctrine encompasses a wide range of political matters—such as the concept of the *Ummah* (the global Muslim community), *Sharia* (Islamic law), and various codes of conduct. The foundational principles underlying these doctrines are considered beyond question.

For instance, the consumption of pork is strictly forbidden for Muslims—it is a major taboo. Yet, does Islamic doctrine contain any higher-level provisions that might allow a Muslim to consume pork under specific circumstances without it being considered a violation of the faith?

While we should certainly respect the customs and beliefs of different groups, today’s global society is an open one, characterized by increasing integration. It is essential for different groups to make mutual compromises regarding their respective customs and beliefs; otherwise, tensions will inevitably intensify, leading to conflicts that could continue to escalate.
My understanding of your post and Kindly correct me if I've missed something, is that You're essentially arguing that as different belief systems increasingly interact, the incompatibilities between some of their foundational principles can create friction, and that mutual compromise is necessary to prevent those differences from escalating into conflict.

I agree that this is a genuine challenge, but I'm not sure the solution requires people to compromise on their fundamental beliefs, or that confrontation is the only solution to that friction

Taking your example of pork, Muslims can retain their religious prohibition without expecting everyone else to observe it. Others can follow their own dietary practices without requiring Muslims to abandon theirs.

I think the same principle can apply to much broader questions of faith, culture and governance. Different communities don't necessarily need to agree on everything, or even reconcile their underlying beliefs. They need a framework that allows them to coexist while respecting each other's rights.

Perhaps the real challenge isn't reconciling fundamentally different belief systems, but establishing the boundaries within which they can coexist.
 
My understanding of your post and Kindly correct me if I've missed something, is that You're essentially arguing that as different belief systems increasingly interact, the incompatibilities between some of their foundational principles can create friction, and that mutual compromise is necessary to prevent those differences from escalating into conflict.

I agree that this is a genuine challenge, but I'm not sure the solution requires people to compromise on their fundamental beliefs, or that confrontation is the only solution to that friction

Taking your example of pork, Muslims can retain their religious prohibition without expecting everyone else to observe it. Others can follow their own dietary practices without requiring Muslims to abandon theirs.

I think the same principle can apply to much broader questions of faith, culture and governance. Different communities don't necessarily need to agree on everything, or even reconcile their underlying beliefs. They need a framework that allows them to coexist while respecting each other's rights.

Perhaps the real challenge isn't reconciling fundamentally different belief systems, but establishing the boundaries within which they can coexist.
Yes, your understanding is correct. However, the latter part of your point touches upon the true crux of the issue.

I am not suggesting that Muslims—or any other group, for that matter—should be required to abandon their own beliefs or traditions. The traditional beliefs and customs of any religion or ethnic group deserve to be respected.

Nevertheless, due to historical factors, certain beliefs and practices held by different groups—whether defined by religion, ethnicity, nationality, or cultural customs—can come into conflict. This is particularly evident in today’s era of increasing global integration.

When I speak of mutual compromise and concession, I am referring to the dynamics that arise when different groups integrate, rather than compromises made within a single, independent group. There is a significant distinction between the two.

Let me provide further examples:

If I—a non-Muslim—were to enter a Muslim-majority environment (such as an Islamic nation or a community designated as Muslim under local law) and openly consume pork, that would clearly be an act of provocation. But let us look at it from the other side: if a Muslim were to enter a non-Muslim community and explicitly demand that others abstain from eating pork, would that also constitute a provocation?
Consider a similar case: Hindus hold cows in high regard and do not consume beef. As non-Hindus, we respect this. However, if Hindus enter non-Hindus communities and openly criticize others for eating beef, is that considered provocation?
Perhaps you might think this is fake news.
At a wet market in Chongqing, China, there is an intriguing sculpture that labels the various edible parts of an entire cow. Such displays are quite common in China.
However, this spot has now become a destination for many Indian social media influencers, who come here to take photos and use them as a pretext to attack China.
1794893904216.png
I fully respect cultural differences among ethnic groups. But we need to distinguish between different situations. Mutual respect, understanding, and compromise are relevant when different groups are in the process of integrating with one another.

If I were to visit an Islamic country or a community governed by Muslim law, I certainly would not consume alcohol or pork. That is a matter of respect. Conversely, if a Muslim enters a non-Muslim community where I live, they cannot demand that I refrain from consuming alcohol or pork. That, too, is a matter of respect. The same principle applies to Hindus or any other group—that is also respect.
 
Pakistani coming generations will understand and then follow Quran one way or the other, I am hopeful.

no doubt be an improvement from the usual meme fiesta that has over taken PdF of late.

Are you blaming @RescueRanger for that? Ban him.


There are many other such examples; I see no need to list them all here. At the very least, we have not seen this type of issue arise within other religions. While it is possible that some smaller religions face similar problems, they are certainly not as prominent as they are in Islam.

Huh, this is a perfect example of how biased one can be and still pretend he is not.

The above paragraph is full of ignorance, depicts veiled hatred and to some extent is reflective of a person who is feeling uncomfortable.

Are you really confused or have a hidden agenda @Michael ?
 
Huh, this is a perfect example of how biased one can be and still pretend he is not.
The above paragraph is full of ignorance, depicts veiled hatred and to some extent is reflective of a person who is feeling uncomfortable.
Are you really confused or have a hidden agenda @Michael ?
I only offer observations based on what I can personally perceive; I refrain from commenting on matters outside my own experience.

For instance:
Consider Judaism—which you seem to harbor hatred toward. It is not recognized as a legal religion under Chinese law, so I have no direct exposure to it. (It is worth noting, however, that one must distinguish between Jewish people and the religion of Judaism.)
Then there is Hinduism. Like Judaism, it is not a legally recognized religion in China. While I do know some Indian friends who practice Hinduism, they have largely set aside the outward, visible manifestations of their faith while in China; in their daily interactions, they are virtually indistinguishable from anyone else. Of course, there are still the occasional Hindu zealots who visit China, but they represent a tiny minority—one that Chinese authorities monitor and address with due seriousness.

Islam, by contrast, is a legally recognized religion in China. Among the four major religions officially permitted in the country, Islam stands out as the most distinct—a point that relates back to the issue I mentioned earlier.

If you think my comments are targeted, that just proves my point—your aggressiveness and unquestionable nature!

To reiterate: I have no intention of causing offense regarding the intrinsic characteristics of any group, including those of the Islamic faith; my focus is simply on observing and analyzing the challenges surrounding the interaction and integration of different groups.
 
Last edited:
Faith and Modernity is not something against to each other. Folks it is Abrahamaic followers that bring modernity to the earth now
 
Consider Judaism—which you seem to harbor hatred toward.

Oh God. Michael, I cannot be a Muslim unless I believe Moses to be true messenger of God and true Torah to be Divine scripture from God.

Now how did you arrive at this conclusion that We Muslims or I harbor hatred towards Judaism? Zionism is not Judaism nor all Jews are Zionists.


If you think my comments are targeted, that just proves my point—your aggressiveness and unquestionable nature!

If you are going to cherry pick and easily forget what Mao did or what Hitler or Stalin did and just try to say that Islam doesn't leave space for questions and compromises, then you are either ignorant or a hypocrite.

What are Buddhists in Burma doing?

You keep mentioning pork, do you know it is also forbidden in old testament of bible? It is also forbidden for observant Jews, and even Hindus.

What will you do if someone attacks China?
 
Yes, your understanding is correct. However, the latter part of your point touches upon the true crux of the issue.

I am not suggesting that Muslims—or any other group, for that matter—should be required to abandon their own beliefs or traditions. The traditional beliefs and customs of any religion or ethnic group deserve to be respected.

Nevertheless, due to historical factors, certain beliefs and practices held by different groups—whether defined by religion, ethnicity, nationality, or cultural customs—can come into conflict. This is particularly evident in today’s era of increasing global integration.

When I speak of mutual compromise and concession, I am referring to the dynamics that arise when different groups integrate, rather than compromises made within a single, independent group. There is a significant distinction between the two.

Let me provide further examples:

If I—a non-Muslim—were to enter a Muslim-majority environment (such as an Islamic nation or a community designated as Muslim under local law) and openly consume pork, that would clearly be an act of provocation. But let us look at it from the other side: if a Muslim were to enter a non-Muslim community and explicitly demand that others abstain from eating pork, would that also constitute a provocation?
Consider a similar case: Hindus hold cows in high regard and do not consume beef. As non-Hindus, we respect this. However, if Hindus enter non-Hindus communities and openly criticize others for eating beef, is that considered provocation?
Perhaps you might think this is fake news.
At a wet market in Chongqing, China, there is an intriguing sculpture that labels the various edible parts of an entire cow. Such displays are quite common in China.
However, this spot has now become a destination for many Indian social media influencers, who come here to take photos and use them as a pretext to attack China.
View attachment 223177
I fully respect cultural differences among ethnic groups. But we need to distinguish between different situations. Mutual respect, understanding, and compromise are relevant when different groups are in the process of integrating with one another.

If I were to visit an Islamic country or a community governed by Muslim law, I certainly would not consume alcohol or pork. That is a matter of respect. Conversely, if a Muslim enters a non-Muslim community where I live, they cannot demand that I refrain from consuming alcohol or pork. That, too, is a matter of respect. The same principle applies to Hindus or any other group—that is also respect.

Non Muslim eating pork in Muslim countries is not some sort of provocation. I dont think simple things like eating or drinking can cause that. The problem is only when you sell something that contain pork ingredient while not saying that openly

You have wrong assumption already.
 
Oh God. Michael, I cannot be a Muslim unless I believe Moses to be true messenger of God and true Torah to be Divine scripture from God.

Now how did you arrive at this conclusion that We Muslims or I harbor hatred towards Judaism? Zionism is not Judaism nor all Jews are Zionists.
If we could all strictly distinguish between Jews, Israel, Judaism, and Zionism... then I would be willing to apologize for my previous remarks.

But the reality—at least on this forum—is that the vast majority of those who follow Islam do not make such clear distinctions between these concepts.

To put it more plainly: China maintains friendly relations with Pakistan. What we recognize is the nation of Pakistan, not its religion. We make a strict distinction between state affairs and religious affairs.

If the Islamic world were able to strictly distinguish between "Jews, Israel, Judaism, and Zionism," I would offer a sincere apology.
If you are going to cherry pick and easily forget what Mao did or what Hitler or Stalin did and just try to say that Islam doesn't leave space for questions and compromises, then you are either ignorant or a hypocrite.
What are Buddhists in Burma doing?
As I have already said, you need to distinguish between political issues and religious issues.
Clearly, the examples you cited fail to make this distinction.
You keep mentioning pork, do you know it is also forbidden in old testament of bible? It is also forbidden for observant Jews, and even Hindus.
Non Muslim eating pork in Muslim countries is not some sort of provocation. I dont think simple things like eating or drinking can cause that. The problem is only when you sell something that contain pork ingredient while not saying that openly
Let’s return to the true core of the issue.

Whether or not Muslims eat pork is their own private matter; no one has the right to interfere. By the same token, Muslims have no right to interfere with whether or not non-Muslims eat pork. This is a matter of respect.

However, instances where Muslims compel non-Muslims to abstain from pork are far from rare.

From what I have observed, Buddhists do not force non-Buddhists to abstain from meat, and in other religions, it is also quite uncommon for believers to prohibit non-believers from engaging in acts that run counter to their own religious doctrines. Yet, with Islam, this issue arises frequently.

I am not suggesting that all Muslims exhibit this behavior. Nevertheless, such incidents occur often within contexts involving Muslims. I do not know whether this aligns with Islamic doctrine, but it certainly creates a negative impression for those outside the faith. If you would like to know the details, I can provide a wealth of evidence.
What will you do if someone attacks China?
Are there not already plenty of instances where the world has attacked China?
 
Disclaimer:

I am fully aware of the sensitive nature of these viewpoints and issues.

I previously asked the administrators whether this discussion should be allowed to continue, and the response from @RescueRanger was that it could proceed...

I hope we can continue with a rational, in-depth discussion. However, this will inevitably touch upon many sensitive topics. If I cause any offense, please let me know—or simply delete my posts. ------ My intention was not to offend any taboo.
 
For instance:
Consider Judaism—which you seem to harbor hatred toward. It is not recognized as a legal religion under Chinese law, so I have no direct exposure to it. (It is worth noting, however, that one must distinguish between Jewish people and the religion of Judaism.)

Judaism is not hated by Muslims. 99 % of Muslim prophet are Judaism prophets as well. Even prophet Muhammad is offspring of Abraham (the father of Abrahamaic religions).

The problem arises when Palestinian genoside happens. Despite that Muslim has been ordered to act fair by their God so we are forbiden to harm any civilians.

If Muslim targeted civilians than it is already outside what their God ordered, so such persons should not be regarded as following his religion, rather they are part of group that is following their hawa (emotional impulse).

Including in PDF, what some members said in here should not be seen as something that is also had in other Muslim minds. Here you can see Palestinan members whose family get real direct affect on Israel aggression as well many Iranian members and also Pakistani shiah members here . You also can also see here Iranian members that actually less religious (as they already proclaim in which only old members here already know)

While some Muslim like Al Qaeda or ISIS do target civilian target but they are very minority within Muslim group and it is normal to have this abnormality within 2 billion Muslim.

-------------

O believers! Stand firm for justice as witnesses for Allah even if it is against yourselves, your parents, or close relatives. Be they rich or poor, Allah is best to ensure their interests. So do not let your desires cause you to deviate ˹from justice˺. If you distort the testimony or refuse to give it, then ˹know that˺ Allah is certainly All-Aware of what you do
 
If the Islamic world were able to strictly distinguish between "Jews, Israel, Judaism, and Zionism," I would offer a sincere apology.

Okay, then you should apologize.

Plenty of Muslims and Islamic country state heads have made this distinction. Even the Palestinians have made this many times.

As I have already said, you need to distinguish between political issues and religious issues.
Clearly, the examples you cited fail to make this distinction.

Mosques should be our center of everything, unfortunately which they are not. But if anyone attacks our mosques, then they attack our politics, they attack our people, they attack our religion, it doesn't matter who they are. And no mercy is to be shown to the aggressors unless they refrain surrender and make peace.

Are there not already plenty of instances where the world has attacked China?

This is not answer to my question. Please be honest and answer my question. What would you do if someone attacks China?
 
Judaism is not hated by Muslims. 99 % of Muslim prophet are Judaism prophets as well. Even prophet Muhammad is offspring of Abraham (the father of Abrahamaic religions).

The problem arises when Palestinian genoside happens. Despite that Muslim has been ordered to act fair by their God so we are forbiden to harm any civilians.

If Muslim targeted civilians than it is already outside what their God ordered, so such persons should not be regarded as following his religion, rather they are part of group that is following their hawa (emotional impulse).

Including in PDF, what some members said in here should not be seen as something that is also had in other Muslim minds. Here you can see Palestinan members whose family get real direct affect on Israel aggression as well many Iranian members and also Pakistani shiah members here . You also can also see here Iranian members that actually less religious (as they already proclaim in which only old members here already know)

While some Muslim like Al Qaeda or ISIS do target civilian target but they are very minority within Muslim group and it is normal to have this abnormality within 2 billion Muslim.

-------------

O believers! Stand firm for justice as witnesses for Allah even if it is against yourselves, your parents, or close relatives. Be they rich or poor, Allah is best to ensure their interests. So do not let your desires cause you to deviate ˹from justice˺. If you distort the testimony or refuse to give it, then ˹know that˺ Allah is certainly All-Aware of what you do
Okay, then you should apologize.
Plenty of Muslims and Islamic country state heads have made this distinction. Even the Palestinians have made this many times.
At the very least, on this forum, many Muslims fail to distinguish between Israel, Israelis, Judaism, and Zionism. When attacking the other side, they frequently resort to broad, sweeping generalizations.

I am well aware that the actions of some Muslims do not represent all Muslims, and that there are diverse, differing tendencies within the Muslim community itself—these are internal matters for the Islamic world.

However, this issue has a tangible impact on how non-Muslims globally perceive the Muslim world as a whole. I fully grasp the complexity of this situation, as China faces a similar challenge today.

For the vast majority of non-Chinese, perceptions of China are shaped by reports in English-language media. While we occasionally criticize these outlets for inaccurate coverage, such efforts are largely ineffective. What truly matters is enabling the world to see the real China.
Consequently, China is continuing to open up, inviting those who harbor doubts to visit in person and experience the reality of the country for themselves.
While heated arguments on social media are real, they, too, represent the actions of a minority.

Yet, religious conduct differs from state action. Even without traveling abroad, one can personally encounter the influence of Islam; it is present all around us.

In recent years, I have been studying South Asia and the Islamic world—which is why I am a frequent participant on this forum (PDF). My long-held, negative impressions have shifted somewhat, though in other respects, the situation has only grown worse.
Mosques should be our center of everything, unfortunately which they are not. But if anyone attacks our mosques, then they attack our politics, they attack our people, they attack our religion, it doesn't matter who they are. And no mercy is to be shown to the aggressors unless they refrain surrender and make peace.
I agree with your point. More precisely, I strongly condemn any act that targets civilian facilities.
However, the real world does not operate according to such ideals.
Soldiers are expected to confront the enemy with courage—that is the norm. In reality, however, many soldiers cowardly hide behind civilians, using them as cannon fodder, only to later level moral accusations against the other side for attacking civilians.

On battlefields across the globe, military forces often use civilian infrastructure as cover to launch attacks, yet they turn around and accuse their adversaries of targeting civilian facilities.

In such cases, whom should we hold responsible first?

Recently, during a military exercise, the Taiwanese armed forces set up a forward command post inside a Guandi Temple. Does this amount to "moral coercion"—using a sacred or civilian space to shield military operations?
1794901915293.png
This is not answer to my question. Please be honest and answer my question. What would you do if someone attacks China?
It depends on how you choose to "attack" China.

If you resort to military action, then, without a doubt, I will fight you with everything I’ve got!

If it’s merely a verbal attack, I’ll first analyze the situation. If I conclude that it stems from a misunderstanding, I will do my best to explain; if I conclude that it’s intentional, I might fire back a few words if I’m in a good mood—or, if I’m not, I’ll simply block and ignore you, not even bothering to respond.
 
At the very least, on this forum, many Muslims fail to distinguish between Israel, Israelis, Judaism, and Zionism. When attacking the other side, they frequently resort to broad, sweeping generalizations.
Not only Muslims, I've seen that "elsewhere", in westerners.

Judaism is 2500 years old, Zionism was only created in the 1890s by a secular, nonreligious Jew who literally believed Jews are assimilating fast and will disappear if they don't have their own state.

The State of Israel itself (de facto) disliked Orthodox Jews for a long time etc.
 
Last edited:

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top