Pakistan-Af: Operation Khyber Storm

[Fasbre2]

Typical .. any military gains lost on the negotiating table by politicians…

 

[Irfan Baloch]

Sir with due respect now you with your hate is crossing the threshold. he is stupid and a fan of imran khan which i dont like but he is the first CM from ex tribal area and is in no way in favor of taliban or TTP. He wants peace thats it so please bas kar dein ap punjab walay har kisi pay ghaddaari ka fatwa na lagaya kren.. yes we have soft corner for people in afghanistan why? first they are muslims and second they are pashtoon also and we have family relations with them but it does not mean we wanted to be their part? they have banned female education and even recent internet ban which is taking those afghan people back to stonge age area which is totally wrong we want education especially in STEM and peace for us and for them as well.

Kabhi ghaur kiya hai? jis baat pay aap ghussa hain aam awam especially PTI jo poori army kay khilaaf bhak rahi hoti.. you are doing the same as you have started hating whole PTI balkay most of pakistani and all of KPK? instead of being mature aur dono side ki ghalat ko ghalat kahnay aur peace aman ki baat karnay kay bajaaye ap dosri side kay extreme pay aakay ab khail rahay?

read my posts about our retaliation in Afghanistan and view about deporting Afghans then you might need to edit your post. there is no hate towards PTI just criticsm on the way it conducts itself on social media. re Afghanistan I draw distincition between its people and the regime.

 

[Liquidator]

Typical .. any military gains lost on the negotiating table by politicians…

Care to elaborate on the gains lost? Just outline the biggest gain "lost".

Thanks

 

[Baibers_1260]

@hussain0216

Brother Hussain,

It's simple closure of border, denial of ports and curtailment of trade that harms Afghanistan

The problem is the blockade will be broken by smuggling with the connivance of authorities.

Regards

The Pakistan Afghan border has 5 checkpoints. There are very few roads to transport bulk goods such as food and duel. The rest of the border consists of "donkey" trails on mountain passes that cannot be used by vehicles. "Donkey back" smuggling of goods has always been present even with the checkpoints open and will continue regardless of what happens elsewhere. However "donkey back" smuggling is insufficient to sustain a poverty stricken landlocked nation entirely dependent on imports from a single country to the east.
This is exactly the dilemma Nepal faces with India. By shutting down just 5 checkpoints India has regularly forced Nepal onto its knees literally begging for the borders to be opened.

Didn't India successfully close the border with Bangladesh after the change of government in Bangladesh? The India-Bangladesh border is approximately 4096 km. Yet it is mostly controlled. However unlike Afghanistan and Nepal Bangladesh has an access to the sea and a couple of good ports . So the Indian closure is not that effective, Additionally the closure of the India Bangladesh border hurts Infia much more because it also closes off land, water and air transit access to India's north eastern states leaving only the Siliguri corridor "chicken's neck" as a point of access.

 

[SABRE]

Typical .. any military gains lost on the negotiating table by politicians…

After Hannibal defeated ~80,000 strong Roman army at the Battle of Canae, one of his officers and personal friend suggested marching to Rome. Hannibal rejected the proposal, leading the officer/friend to state something along the lines of "You know how to achieve victory, Hannibal, but you don't know what to with it."

That said, sometimes peace treaties appear disadvantageous but they prove to be beneficial in the long run. Example: the Peace of Hudebya. There is no chance that Taliban would keep their end of the bargain, simply because they cannot. Fighting/militancy is their economy. When Pakistani support ended they turned to the one willing to fund them - India. When they break the peace is when they reveal their true self. That's the time when you strike them. In the meantime, Pakistan needs to strengthen itself. Systematically take action against the miscreants on this side of the border so they won't be nuisance when the military action restarts.

 

[RescueRanger]

Yes. I think we have different threshhold. She is defaming at some places but not involved in anti-national activities. Perhaps, you may know more as you consider Moeed on payroll and a pseudo intellectual.

PECA is very clear on the threshold. Remember the tale of the camel and the tent.

Some boundaries must be maintained.

 

[Tariq Habib Afridi]

Don't take it to your heart , it's just a competition of witts and patriotism.....on a serious note,...how can you open schools in terrorism infested areas ? When Teachers aren't willing to go there and parents are not willing to send their kids to school .

That is what the new CM with core commander kpk should investigate and find out

 

[R2D2]

Care to cite examples of neither here nor there? No laws repugnant to religion can be formulated in Pakistan. If Talib means student, they can study Pakistan movement and Pakistani constitution and get enlightened anytime they like.

A reference to Qauid's quote would also be appreciated regarding state sponsored state religion and right of government to experiment accordingly in executive authority.

Objective Resolution was framed after the death of the Founder of Pakistan. It's considered a brainchild of Nawab Liaquat.

We have a banking system based on Interest. In Islamic mode of partnership, the one who invests the money also takes the risk in case of a loss. In Jewish Banking, in case of loss, the bank takes no loss and instead takes the borrower's land or other collateral.

Quaid's whole Pakistan movement was based on the slogan of La Ilaha Illal Lah. If not real, then the government must declare that it just was a political slogan and had nothing to do with the actual aims of the Pakistan movement.

Islam has its own social system based on family values which has survived to this day and is being eroded due to western influence and media.

Islam has its own judicial laws which are completely different from the amended Government of India Act that we have applied in Pakistan.

Islam has its own concept of Ummah which does not believe in borders between Muslims. It can be best implemented by having a European Union and NATO type of Union between the Muslim countries so that we become a power and can face challenges like Palestine jointly.

 

[Taimoor]

I won't say all of them but let me ask a question?
1-Do they stick to that oath?
2-If you violate a oath whats the punishment?
3-Are they involved in politics even when they are strictly prohibited not to?
4-If not just them lets say chief justices or Prime ministers (lets say Shareefs, Zadaris or IK) or any other civil employee or servant violates there oath should they be treated same way they(DHA builders) are treated or do the builders get jail free cards like always?

These are the questions, those who have loyalty to GHQ (not Pakistan) will never answer with straight face. The idea of submitting to the will of the citizens is alien to them.

 

[RescueRanger]

You will reap what you sow.

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

Accept third party cookies

 

[Bilal]

You will reap what you sow.

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

Accept third party cookies

We don’t host NRF. But we don’t consider NRF terrorists. They have legitimate concerns that Taliban regime should address through talks.

 

[El Sidd]

We have a banking system based on Interest. In Islamic mode of partnership, the one who invests the money also takes the risk in case of a loss. In Jewish Banking, in case of loss, the bank takes no loss and instead takes the borrower's land or other collateral.

Quaid's whole Pakistan movement was based on the slogan of La Ilaha Illal Lah. If not real, then the government must declare that it just was a political slogan and had nothing to do with the actual aims of the Pakistan movement.

Islam has its own social system based on family values which has survived to this day and is being eroded due to western influence and media.

Islam has its own judicial laws which are completely different from the amended Government of India Act that we have applied in Pakistan.

Islam has its own concept of Ummah which does not believe in borders between Muslims. It can be best implemented by having a European Union and NATO type of Union between the Muslim countries so that we become a power and can face challenged like Palestine jointly.

Not looking for rhetoric but asked for specifics in the constitution. Yes, interest based economic system is not ideologically aligned with the state religion and framework has been deliberated to avoid it altogether. It's a continuous ideological struggle to an evolving construct I.e. socio-economics.

Pakistan provides preferential treatment to Muslim majority countries without harboring desires of exploitation or anything detrimental to their sovereignty. This is documented history which is witness to any communal obligation towards a wider concept of supernation or Ummatul Muslimeen.

As far as some Dhul Qarnayn federation is concerned, it already exists in shared delusions carried by those who indulge in idealism and romanticism.

 

[R2D2]

Not looking for rhetoric but asked for specifics in the constitution. Yes, interest based economic system is not ideologically aligned with the state religion and framework has been deliberated to avoid it altogether. It's a continuous ideological struggle to an evolving construct I.e. socio-economics.

Pakistan provides preferential treatment to Muslim majority countries without harboring desires of exploitation or anything detrimental to their sovereignty. This is documented history which is witness to any communal obligation towards a wider concept of supernation or Ummatul Muslimeen.

As far as some Dhul Qarnayn federation is concerned, it already exists in shared delusions carried by those who indulge in idealism and romanticism.

It is not a delusion. It was a historical fact from he times of the Companions of the Prophet (PBUH) to 1924.

 

[hasssanali8998]

You will reap what you sow.

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

Accept third party cookies

we should definitely support them , lets see how they like it when bombings happen to their forces

 

[Hakikat ve Hikmet]

we should definitely support them , lets see how they like it when bombings happen to their forces

50 shades of grey....