BJP Labels All Muslims in India As Traitors

There is a significant difference. Indian Muslims are "Indians", they are not some outsiders/refugees.

*Some* Afghans being branded as such is different because in Pakistan, they are foreign nationals living on the soil, taking from it, and abusing the hospitality and in extreme cases, joining hands with inimical forces against Pakistan and murdering/destroying Pakistanis/Pakistani property.
still, a sweeping statement is unjust. We cannot blame an entire race, nation, ethnicity, etc for wrong. Perhaps, true for Israelis, despite a good minority that is anti-war.
 
You are asking me to take you down the rabbit hole.

We both know such discussion isn't possible on this forum.

A neutral western forum would be for suited for it.
No, I'm pointing out that this argument has no applicability in the current age

You might be leading to other points from this but unless we frankly discuss them we can only discuss said points and they are outdated
 
Then will We treat the Muslims like the Mujrims (criminals)? What is [the matter] with you? How do you judge? (Sura Al Qalam, Ayet#35-36)

Thanks to GOD for the Two Nation Theory.....

The BD Muslims reinforced TNT by killing Mujib and eradicating Hasina, the principal tools of the Ram Rajya of the Hindutva Bharat to reinitiate the Permanent Settlement (The British Raj policy to make a permanent underclass out of the Muslims in Bengal).....
 
Last edited:
No Different Than Us Labelling Afghans As Namak Haram
Awwww another Afghanistan lover spotted. How about you open your door and keep some.

Indian muslims have been living in India for over 1000 years so not same as illegal afgans in Pakistan.
 
That is an example of lack of IQ application from Indian govt (in particular Ministry of Education). However, I grew up at a time when the "expunged" sections were taught and discussed at length. In any case, can you/fellow members respond to the substantive part of argument which is:
1. Can you point one govt policy which is discriminating against Muslims? Any one bayaan (on official or unofficial channel) of Modi or any of the top cabinet members?

2. How do you see the contrast between India elevating a scientist such as APJ to top position while Absum Salam leaving Pakistan for good?
 
The Pakistani posters and narratives are some of the cringest narratives in online history. These mofukers are weird as fuk.

I am weirded out everytime I see their talking points.

The strange thing is that they actully hate the Indian muslims more then the Indian Hindus hate the Indian muslims.

Pakistanis are the weirdest bunch you will come across in this forum or in real life. Complex idiots.

They also happen to hate the Afghans more then the Hindus and they claim Pakistan is home of the muslims but they are actully closet anti-islamists.

The Hindus are much better because atleast they are what they say
Why are you malding?
 
`
1. Yes, so the whole sentiment behind the bill is: Non Muslims have faced persecution in neighboring countries and sought refuge in India (and you can check the numbers, they are miniscule). So anyone inside before 2014, will be a citizen - you know how many Hindus, Jains, Sikhs etc are in the Muslim dominated neighborhood so in effect its a few thousand people maybe

2. Then it doesn't say that Muslims before 2014 who have migrated from neighboring countries can't be Indian citizens/go through the process, it doesn't grant that right automatically. The rationale is that the Muslims have migrated for economic reasons, not religious persecution.

3. Then it lays down a framework for any citizen requests (regardless of religion) for anyone entering India post 2014

The argument in #2 is not far from what US and many other countries are doing i.e., people who are migrating for pure economic reasons and not to seek refuge from govts/other groups will not be considered aliens/granted citizenship outright.
So in essence, you are saying that the laws in question are discriminatory but at the same time they are not?

Yes. Carry on. Nobody will notice behind the shroud of obfuscation.

We have not even discussed inequitable application of law:





, but we don't really need to go there, as the Secular Republic of Hindustan makes it abundantly clear that the Muslim demographic is to be weaponised whenever accusations of inequality are tabled, but nothing more.
 
Why are you malding?

Because you guys are delusional but you don´t see yourself.

Everyone´s shxt smells good to themselves.

I hate the narratives like some of the elements go with here ´´Oh Wow the Indian muslims should have joined us bla bla and it is their fault yada yada´´ How fuk can around 40-50m muslims back then just join Pakistan who are not local to the IVC but local to the subcontinent? It doesn´t make sense
 
Because you guys are delusional but you don´t see yourself.

Everyone´s shxt smells good to themselves
Mercifully, not one single shxt, good smelling or otherwise, is being given about your opinion.
 
For arguments sake, let us accept these points, they would still only be applicable to voters of that era

What agency does this line of reasoning have on current crop of Indian muslims, do they inherit the traitorship or as the constitution says, are considered Indian citizens

No, I'm pointing out that this argument has no applicability in the current age

You might be leading to other points from this but unless we frankly discuss them we can only discuss said points and they are outdated
You insisted on going down the rabbit hole. So I reluctantly obliged. Just issuing a clarification.

If you say what's happened in the past, doesn't apply to the current era. Then same logic applies to the constitution which was written in the past without consulting ordinary citizens. The constitution isn't same as asmani kitab which cannot be changed.

Non Muslims didn't ask for a separate country. Muslims did.

Punjabi Hindus and Sikhs, Bengali Hindus and Sindhi Hindus were wealthy and hardworking compared to their Muslim counterparts. It's documented history. The former lost everything. While the later captured their wealth.

India had to accomodate to the expelled Hindu and Sikh folks. India still has to accomodate refugees from Pakistan and Bangladesh. Also illegal Muslim immigrants.

Pakistan and Bangladesh both promised religious freedom and protection of their non Muslim minorities. But they didn't fulfil the promise. Indian Muslims might face discrimination but never heard cases of their underage females being abducted and forcibly converted to Hinduism. They are found in Bollywood,media,civil services, private jobs, etc. They are a visible minority.

Partition was unfair to Non Muslims. Muslims gained from the partition as there was no total exchange of population. Non Muslims of India too point out that Indian Muslims have special rights compared to others. So they say India too belongs to Muslims first and foremost like Pakistan and Bangladesh. Former PM Manmohan Singh said that too.

If Congress would have conducted a referendum among Hindus and Sikhs of India whether they wanted Muslims out of India. Even most of Congress supporting Hindus and Sikhs would have voted for emigration of Muslims to West and East Pakistan. But the Congress never did that. They wanted Muslims to stay for their votebank politics. This unfair decision is still affecting non Muslim majority of India.

Going by your logic, the current majority of India doesn't have to abide by the unfair constitution which was written in the past, the terms of unfair partition and unfair decisions of the Congress which were taken in the past.

@Vapnope
 
Last edited:
You insisted on going down the rabbit hole. So I reluctantly obliged. Just issuing a clarification.

If you say what's happened in the past, doesn't apply to the current era. Then same logic applies to the constitution which was written in the past without consulting ordinary citizens. The constitution isn't same as asmani kitab which cannot be changed.

Non Muslims didn't ask for a separate country. Muslims did.

Punjabi Hindus and Sikhs, Bengali Hindus and Sindhi Hindus were wealthy and hardworking compared to their Muslim counterparts. It's documented history. The former lost everything. While the later captured their wealth.

India had to accomodate to the expelled Hindu and Sikh folks. India still has to accomodate refugees from Pakistan and Bangladesh. Also illegal Muslim immigrants.

Pakistan and Bangladesh both promised religious freedom and protection of their non Muslim minorities. But they didn't fulfil the promise. Indian Muslims might face discrimination but never heard cases of their underage females being abducted and forcibly converted to Hinduism. They are found in Bollywood,media,civil services, private jobs, etc. They are a visible minority.

Partition was unfair to Non Muslims. Muslims gained from the partition as there was no total exchange of population. Non Muslims of India too point out that Indian Muslims have special rights compared to others. So they say India too belongs to Muslims first and foremost like Pakistan and Bangladesh. Former PM Manmohan Singh said that too.

If Congress would have conducted a referendum among Hindus and Sikhs of India whether they wanted Muslims out of India. Even most of Congress supporting Hindus and Sikhs would have voted for emigration of Muslims to West and East Pakistan. But the Congress never did that. They wanted Muslims to stay for their votebank politics. This unfair decision is still affecting non Muslim majority of India.

Going by your logic, the current majority of India doesn't have to abide by the unfair constitution which was written in the past, the terms of unfair partition and unfair decisions of the Congress which were taken in the past.

@Vapnope

Your argument mixes unrelated issues and uses selective history to justify it

1. comparing the Constitution to partition politics is misleading. The Constitution wasn’t written to favor one community — it was written to protect every Indian equally. It has been amended over a hundred times, proving it’s not a rigid “asmani kitab,” but a living document that evolves with the nation’s values.

2. Blaming one community for the Partition ignores historical nuance. The Muslim League led that demand, but millions of Muslims — especially in what became India — opposed Partition and chose to stay in a secular India. They didn’t “gain” from it; they faced suspicion and hardship for decades.

3. The suffering of Hindus and Sikhs during Partition was immense and undeniable, but pain was on both sides. Millions of Muslims were also killed, displaced, and left destitute when they migrated to Pakistan.

4. Pointing to refugee crises or illegal immigration today doesn’t justify discrimination. Those are governance issues, not grounds for collective blame. Citizenship and equality under the Constitution are about individual rights, not inherited guilt from 1947.

Saying “the majority doesn’t have to abide by an unfair Constitution” is exactly what undermines democracy. The Constitution is what ensures that majorities don’t trample minorities. Rejecting it because it protects everyone equally isn’t strength — it’s regression.

So, yes — we should learn from the past, but not weaponize it to justify new injustices
 
You insisted on going down the rabbit hole. So I reluctantly obliged. Just issuing a clarification.

If you say what's happened in the past, doesn't apply to the current era. Then same logic applies to the constitution which was written in the past without consulting ordinary citizens. The constitution isn't same as asmani kitab which cannot be changed.

Non Muslims didn't ask for a separate country. Muslims did.

Punjabi Hindus and Sikhs, Bengali Hindus and Sindhi Hindus were wealthy and hardworking compared to their Muslim counterparts. It's documented history. The former lost everything. While the later captured their wealth.

India had to accomodate to the expelled Hindu and Sikh folks. India still has to accomodate refugees from Pakistan and Bangladesh. Also illegal Muslim immigrants.

Pakistan and Bangladesh both promised religious freedom and protection of their non Muslim minorities. But they didn't fulfil the promise. Indian Muslims might face discrimination but never heard cases of their underage females being abducted and forcibly converted to Hinduism. They are found in Bollywood,media,civil services, private jobs, etc. They are a visible minority.

Partition was unfair to Non Muslims. Muslims gained from the partition as there was no total exchange of population. Non Muslims of India too point out that Indian Muslims have special rights compared to others. So they say India too belongs to Muslims first and foremost like Pakistan and Bangladesh. Former PM Manmohan Singh said that too.

If Congress would have conducted a referendum among Hindus and Sikhs of India whether they wanted Muslims out of India. Even most of Congress supporting Hindus and Sikhs would have voted for emigration of Muslims to West and East Pakistan. But the Congress never did that. They wanted Muslims to stay for their votebank politics. This unfair decision is still affecting non Muslim majority of India.

Going by your logic, the current majority of India doesn't have to abide by the unfair constitution which was written in the past, the terms of unfair partition and unfair decisions of the Congress which were taken in the past.

@Vapnope


Kya gobbar arguments hai bey... current majority of India definitely can change the constitution but through due process. The terms of partition and the decisions might seem unfair to you but for many Indians they are not. Moreover, most Indians want to live in present and build for future - dwelling on the past is just a time pass.

India is a richer country due to Muslims, Jains, Buddhists, other faiths. India is not for Hindus alone and no faith has the "first" right to India's resources. And IMO, Pakistan and Bangladesh are poorer due to lack of religious diversity/freedom.

Beyond religion, 99% of people in sub-continent are descendants of Sanatan. Sub-continent (and now India) is an ocean where rivers of all faiths, believers and non-believers, end-up. It has always absorbed diversity and hopefully will continue to do so. Most of us have forgotten where we come from - not religion but the ethos we are/were harbingers off - where challenging God is accepted, where there is no one right or wrong, where religion is not used to oppress

Its easy to hate, but remember the thing/person you're hating is also a product (and has the same essence as you) of supreme consciousness who you seek
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Pakistan Defence Latest

Country Watch Latest

Back
Top