China and India - How is India viewed in China?

There are two China's and chinamen that exist for any country with free media and Internet access-

1- the overwhelming Chinese shills who flood forums like this and more popular ones like Quora and Reddit with pro CCP content; for example you probably have come across posts glorifying railways in China are making it's first profit for the first time ever, but they would have never criticized the loss they made over the last twenty years

2- You get to meet some real Chinese, real common men who have loved and experienced some freedom, and aren't paid shills, they are very much like you and me who work hard take care of their families, the first words out of their mouth will not be how the great Chinese nation is doing under CCP.

There is a crude nuance to Ident these kinds and consequently how one views and treats them.
The one-sided categorization of any group is in itself an act of hatred! So, please stop your behavior!

This is not a rational attitude!

People will behave at certain times or in certain situations, because of certain factors. But you can't assume that this person is a certain kind of person. The same is true of the country!

We need to conduct in-depth analysis and research on some seemingly simple behaviors in order to find the causes of these behaviors. This is the attitude and way that academic research should have!

============================================

片面的将任何群体分类,这本身就是一种仇视行为!所以,请停止你这种行为!

这不是一个理性的态度!

人在某些时候或者某些情况下,因为某些因素,会做出某些行为。但你不能就此认定此人是某种人。国家亦是如此!

我们需要对一些看似简单的行为进行深入分析和研究,从而找到诱发这些行为的原因。这才是学术研究应该有的态度和方式!
 
There is no hatred against Hinduism in China, nor is there any animosity in India toward the religion practiced by the Chinese. However, this is not the case with India’s relations with Pakistan and Bangladesh, where hatred against Hindus is taught in Pakistani textbooks. I’m not attributing this to Islam as a whole, because such hatred is not seen in the rest of the Muslim world. This hostility towards Hinduism is specific to the Muslims of the Indian subcontinent.
Religious issues are beyond the scope of this thread. Please don't get involved in any religious issues!
 
There are two China's and chinamen that exist for any country with free media and Internet access-

1- the overwhelming Chinese shills who flood forums like this and more popular ones like Quora and Reddit with pro CCP content; for example you probably have come across posts glorifying railways in China are making it's first profit for the first time ever, but they would have never criticized the loss they made over the last twenty years

2- You get to meet some real Chinese, real common men who have loved and experienced some freedom, and aren't paid shills, they are very much like you and me who work hard take care of their families, the first words out of their mouth will not be how the great Chinese nation is doing under CCP.

There is a crude nuance to Ident these kinds and consequently how one views and treats them.

I have never had hate or even dislike for any of the paid or unpaid Chinese shills - more of annoyance at worst
 
People who do not analyze India-China relations by the words exchanged on PDF by respective members, will know that there is a lot of trade and co-operation going on between the two countries, even despite the lethal border clashes we had a few years ago.

This is an interesting article about Chinese engineers working in the southern state of Tamil Nadu:

Inside Foxconn’s struggle to make iPhones in India

It is an engrossing but long read, so I am not copy-pasting the entire article here.

@Joe Shearer @Michael
 
The one-sided categorization of any group is in itself an act of hatred! So, please stop your behavior!

This is not a rational attitude!

People will behave at certain times or in certain situations, because of certain factors. But you can't assume that this person is a certain kind of person. The same is true of the country!

We need to conduct in-depth analysis and research on some seemingly simple behaviors in order to find the causes of these behaviors. This is the attitude and way that academic research should have!

============================================

片面的将任何群体分类,这本身就是一种仇视行为!所以,请停止你这种行为!

这不是一个理性的态度!

人在某些时候或者某些情况下,因为某些因素,会做出某些行为。但你不能就此认定此人是某种人。国家亦是如此!

我们需要对一些看似简单的行为进行深入分析和研究,从而找到诱发这些行为的原因。这才是学术研究应该有的态度和方式!
Oh no no no, no hatred, just comical laughs at the shills.

There also is no element of categorization in that statement, it is not what you seem to believe is.

Maybe there is some translated error introduced here, because you seem to be reading what is written translated to Mandarin ,very hard with that.
 
I have never had hate or even dislike for any of the paid or unpaid Chinese shills - more of annoyance at worst

Me no hate either, just have some laughs at the crude efforts
 
People who do not analyze India-China relations by the words exchanged on PDF by respective members, will know that there is a lot of trade and co-operation going on between the two countries, even despite the lethal border clashes we had a few years ago.

This is an interesting article about Chinese engineers working in the southern state of Tamil Nadu:

Inside Foxconn’s struggle to make iPhones in India

It is an engrossing but long read, so I am not copy-pasting the entire article here.

@Joe Shearer @Michael
This is a very good and meaningful start. This kind of communication allows people to really get to know each other.

About "Foxconn in India".

I have seen a lot of analysis and reporting, including Chinese mainland media, Taiwan media, Hong Kong media and some international media with wide influence. We know the impact of this event on India.

It can be very interesting to look at the same event from many different angles.

======================

这是一个非常良好和有意义的开始。这种交流可以让大家彼此真正认识对方。

关于“富士康在印度”。

我看过很多分析和报道,包括中国大陆媒体、台湾媒体、香港媒体和一些具有广泛影响力的国际媒体。我们知道这个事件对于印度的影响力。

从很多不同角度看同一个事件,会是非常有趣的事情。
 
Both India and China are large countries, Long lasting Civilisations

Once a Country reaches a certain level of development
They really don't care what anybody thinks about them

Because No Country is perfect

There are problems in all Countries

What matters is whether a Country is on a Certain and Definitive Positive Trajectory
 
What Chinese think of India does not matter at all. What matters is, what the CCP/ Chinese government thinks of India.
 
People to people interaction between chinise and indian is extremely low. So we don't really know enough to care or hate.
 
My intention was to explore some of the reasons why India hates China (or India thinks China hates India). I don't know much about the professional members on the PDF, so I'm sending you an invitation to start the conversation.

For such controversial topics, we cannot look at the problem from a single angle one-sidedly, and we need to take different standpoints. If we only report and analyze through the Chinese media or the India media, we cannot see the essence of the problem.

Of course, this topic will inevitably extend to the broader Sino-Indian relationship. We can set up a topic for in-depth discussion on the causes of the current tension between China and India, which is more in line with the purpose of having an active in-depth discussion between the two sides. We can start with hot-button issues such as economic confrontation or military confrontation, so as to appropriately extend the broader Sino-Indian relationship.

Like what
India friends expressed concern about the current situation of China's troops stationed in the border areas, believing that this is China's "military threat" against India and planning to carry out "armed aggression" against India. I can make a rational analysis of these military deployments from the perspective of Chinese................
The India government's "economic blackmail" against some Chinese-invested companies in India has made Chinese companies very worried. Friends India can analyze these events from the perspective of India people...................
and so on

@Nilgiri I took a very good look at the "india-China relations" thread. It seems to have been heavily tainted (There are some guys that have been ignored by me, I can't see the full content, and I don't want to see these either). Whether it's continuing the original thread or restarting a new thread, I'm fine. But I hope it's a very rigorous discussion, and I don't want to be ruined by some ignorant nasty people, and that requires some effort on your part from the members of the management team..................

If you decide to start a new thread, you can either move the original statement over or start over completely. Some of the already widely considered nuisances can be banned from this new thread outright. While this may not seem like the rules of an open forum, I think it's a necessary step given the precedent of the destruction of many of PDF's great topics.

@Joe Shearer, the link you provided is completely inaccessible to me.

============================================================

我的本意,是希望对印度仇视中国(或者印度认为中国仇视印度)的原因进行一些探讨。我对PDF上的专业成员了解不多,所以才向您发出邀请,开启这个话题。

对于这种争议话题,不能片面的从单一角度看待问题,需要不同立场的态度。如果我们只通过中国媒体或者印度媒体的报道和分析,是无法看清问题的本质。

当然,这种话题会不可避免的延申到更为广泛的中印关系。我们可以建立一个对当前中印关系紧张的原因进行深度讨论的话题,这更符合彼此之间进行积极的深度讨论的目的。我们可以从经济对抗或者军事对抗这些热点问题开始,从而适度延申更为广泛的中印关系。

比如
印度朋友对当前中国在边境地区驻军的情况表示担忧,认为这是中国对印度实施"军事威胁",计划对印度实施"武装侵略"。我可以从中国人的角度来对这些军事部署做理性的分析................
印度政府对一些中国在印度投资的企业实施"经济讹诈",让中国企业非常担忧。各位印度朋友可以从印度人的角度来分析这些事件...................
诸如此类形式的互动

@Nilgiri 我非常认真的看了“india-china relations”线程。它似乎已经被严重污染(有一些家伙已经被我忽视,我看不到完整的内容,我也不想看到这些)。无论是继续原来的线程,还是重新开启一个新的线程,我都没问题。但我希望是一个非常严谨的讨论,不希望被一些无知的讨厌鬼破坏,这需要你们管理组成员做出一些努力..................

如果你们决定重新开启一个新的线程,可以将原来的发言转移过来,也可以完全重新开始。可以将一些已经被广泛认为的讨厌鬼直接禁止进入这个新的线程。虽然看上去这不符合公开论坛的规矩,但基于PDF众多优秀话题被破坏的先例,我认为这是必须的措施。

@Joe Shearer 你提供的链接我也完全无法访问。
Bold part. I'll give you an honest view.
Before Galwan, No.. Most of the people never hated China in India since I born. I don't know about how India viewed China exact after 1962. But since 80's Mostly Indians views china as competitive, not an enemy. But yeah, insecurities were always there in India's govt and people's mind about China. People in India those who having interest in geopolitics always used to think that one day China surely attack India. But never hated. Indians always praise China's progress and the way lifted herself from poverty. Some people even support China directly as we are democracy we let them speak.

But after Galwan, things have changed. Mostly Indians now view China as first enemy. Militarily our all weapons points towards China only after Galwan. China is the first threat to us now. But but.. We still don't hate you. We just want to solve issues between both. And its very much on China as it has bigger land than India.
India and China has just one issue. LAC. If China really want asian century, it need to sacrifice some land to India peacefully. Without solving India and China border issue we can't even imagine an asian century. These two big civilizations should never go for a war. It will bring the western domination to aisa again. They will grip asia again.
So for the better future of asia, India and China must solve the border issue and dominant the world like an ancient time.
This is how India views China.
 
Well your friend did get banned for calling me Hindu, poor him and you.😁
You ought to stop this right here, and return to the topic.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top