Floods dash Nepal's China trade hopes, entrench reliance on India

[NeptunesVortex]

@Nimble

 

[Nimble]

No matter how much China reinvest on reinfrastructure Nepal connectivity with India is always natural, smooth and cost effective.... Nepal suddenly approving infrastructure projects with China was nothing but to pressure India....

Trade with India can be done without wasting billions on infrastructure as Nepal on India side sits on plain open landscape of UP and Bihar compared to huge Himalayan ranges on the side of China.... whenever be it a trade or natural disaster happen India is the most natural option....

 

[ety]

No matter how much China reinvest on reinfrastructure Nepal connectivity with India is always natural, smooth and cost effective.... Nepal suddenly approving infrastructure projects with China was nothing but to pressure India....

Trade with India can be done without wasting billions on infrastructure as Nepal on India side sits on plain open landscape of UP and Bihar compared to huge Himalayan ranges on the side of China.... whenever be it a trade or natural disaster happen India is the most natural option....

You know why Canada doesn't want to trade and tie up that much with the US now despite many advantages in doing business with US ?

 

[Nimble]

You know why Canada doesn't want to trade and tie up that much with the US now despite many advantages in doing business with US ?

You can't compare Canada America trade relations with Nepal India relations.... dynamics are totally different.... what Canada can offer and what Nepal can offer there is a difference.... Unlike Canada Nepal is underdeveloped landlocked country and India has always given all privileges to Nepal whenever it's required....

My history teacher told me only once in 1989 India and Nepal had tensed situation and out of 15 border gates India closed 13 gates but still kept 2 open.... and after the ease they were all functional again.... research what kind of monetary, technical, medical help India keeps giving Nepal irrespective of Nepal again and again blackmailing India using china card....

Nepal and India has roti beti (bread and daughter) types relations since ages.... citizens of Nepal can even walk In India do jobs or do business and go back or can stay..... it simply cannot be compared to America and Canada... .. can you compare china Mongolia trade and ties with china America?

 

[ety]

You can't compare Canada America trade relations with Nepal India relations.... dynamics are totally different.... what Canada can offer and what Nepal can offer there is a difference.... Unlike Canada Nepal is underdeveloped landlocked country and India has always given all privileges to Nepal whenever it's required....

My history teacher told me only once in 1989 India and Nepal had tensed situation and out of 15 border gates India closed 13 gates but still kept 2 open.... and after the ease they were all functional again.... research what kind of monetary, technical, medical help India keeps giving Nepal irrespective of Nepal again and again blackmailing India using china card....

Nepal and India has roti beti (bread and daughter) types relations since ages.... citizens of Nepal can even walk In India do jobs or do business and go back or can stay..... it simply cannot be compared to America and Canada... .. can you compare china Mongolia trade and ties with china America?

Hey, many Canadians see Americans as cousins, that's how close the relation between the two countries are or at least were. Then, why Nepal and nearly all countries in South Asia want to move away from India and move closer and trade more with China ? That's something Indians have to ponder.

 

[Panda_Hi]

The Nepalese government has taken the initiative to ask China for help in rebuilding the trade corridor between the two countries, and Beijing has already expressed its support.


https://kathmandupost.com/money/202...or-rebuilding-flood-ravaged-rasuwagadhi-route

--------------------​

I know about the relationship between India and Japan, and I also know that India and Japan have worked together for many years to counter China's rise.

But as a Taiwanese, I personally suggest that when it comes to reports about China, Indians should avoid relying on Japanese media as much as possible.

I have read a lot of Japanese news over the years. Because of Japan's anti-China stance, Japanese media often reports on China in a biased way or contains inaccurate information. Sometimes, they even deliberately lead people to have a wrong understanding of the situation, to a degree that you Indians may find hard to imagine.

At this moment, Japan is the country most afraid of China's resurgence. No other country comes close.

Because of the issues left over from World War II, Japan's anxiety about China is far greater than that of the United States or India.

 

[Nimble]

Hey, many Canadians see Americans as cousins, that's how close the relation between the two countries are or at least were. Then, why Nepal and nearly all countries in South Asia want to move away from India and move closer and trade more with China ? That's something Indians have to ponder.

Yes and that's why they are advanced nation and it's big maritime country where it doesn't have to depend on neighbors....

Nepal irrespective of having smooth and best connectivity with India keeps blackmailing India playing China card and still India is always there to offer help in tough times....

Canada is rich, big maritime country and very advanced country.... Canada will survive without USA.... Nepal cannot completely boycott India and stay depend on China...

 

[Panda_Hi]

You can't compare Canada America trade relations with Nepal India relations.... dynamics are totally different.... what Canada can offer and what Nepal can offer there is a difference.... Unlike Canada Nepal is underdeveloped landlocked country and India has always given all privileges to Nepal whenever it's required....

My history teacher told me only once in 1989 India and Nepal had tensed situation and out of 15 border gates India closed 13 gates but still kept 2 open.... and after the ease they were all functional again.... research what kind of monetary, technical, medical help India keeps giving Nepal irrespective of Nepal again and again blackmailing India using china card....

Nepal and India has roti beti (bread and daughter) types relations since ages.... citizens of Nepal can even walk In India do jobs or do business and go back or can stay..... it simply cannot be compared to America and Canada... .. can you compare china Mongolia trade and ties with china America?

bread and daughter?

So after Nepal’s constitutional amendments, can Madhesi people who obtained Nepalese citizenship by birth or naturalization now run for president of Nepal?

The answer is no...

Nepal still has a considerable degree of distrust toward you Indians.

 

[ety]

Yes and that's why they are advanced nation and it's big maritime country where it doesn't have to depend on neighbors....

Nepal irrespective of having smooth and best connectivity with India keeps blackmailing India playing China card and still India is always there to offer help in tough times....

Canada is rich, big maritime country and very advanced country.... Canada will survive without USA.... Nepal cannot completely boycott India and stay depend on China...

Nepal and India have periodic tensions primarily due to territorial disputes, historical border mapping disagreements, and geopolitical balancing involving China. [1, 2, 3]

Key Issues Causing Tensions

• • The Kalapani-Lipulekh-Limpiyadhura Dispute: Both countries claim a 338-square-kilometer strip of high-altitude land near the India-Nepal-China trijunction. Nepal bases its claim on the 1816 Treaty of Sugauli regarding the origin of the Kali River, while India cites its own historical administrative control and security needs. Tensions flared recently when India and China resumed religious pilgrimages and built infrastructure through the contested Lipulekh pass without Kathmandu's consent. [1, 2, 3, 4]
  • Map Controversies: Nepal updated its national map in 2020 to explicitly include the disputed territories, and recent political debates under Prime Minister Balendra Shah have kept territorial sovereignty at the forefront of domestic politics. [1, 2, 3, 4]
  • Geopolitical Influence of China: As a landlocked nation, Nepal relies heavily on India for transit, trade, and energy. However, Kathmandu also seeks closer economic ties with China to diversify its partnerships, which often triggers security concerns in New Delhi regarding its strategic buffer zone.

Tensions and mistrust between some people in Nepal and India stem from a mix of geographical dependency, historical grievances, and perceived political interference. [1, 2]

Geographic and Economic Dependence

• • Landlocked Vulnerability: Nepal relies heavily on India for transit routes, trade access, petroleum, and essential supplies, as most of its international trade is routed through Indian ports. [1, 2]
  • Economic Blockades: Unofficial economic blockades—such as the severe disruptions in 1989 and following the 2015 earthquakes—left lasting scars. Many Nepalis view these blockades as high-handed pressure tactics by a larger neighbor. [1, 2, 3]

Border and Territorial Disputes

• • Kalapani and Lipulekh: Unilateral infrastructure projects and differing maps have sparked sharp territorial disputes over border regions like Kalapani, Lipulekh, and Susta. [1, 2]
  • Border Management: Incidents involving cross-border security forces, unmanaged boundaries, and friction at checkpoints have occasionally led to local friction and accusations of encroachment. [1]

Perceived Political Interference

• • "Big Brother" Attitude: Many in Nepal feel that New Delhi treats Kathmandu as a subordinate security buffer rather than a fully equal sovereign state. [1, 2]
  • Domestic Politics: Accusations of covert or overt Indian involvement in Nepal’s internal political transitions frequently surface, and various Nepali political factions have historically used anti-India sentiment to rally nationalist support. [1, 2]

Resource and Treaties Concerns

• • Unequal Treaties: Landmark agreements, such as the 1950 Treaty of Peace and Friendship, are criticized by critics in Nepal as outdated or lopsided, negotiated under unequal historical circumstances. [1]
  • Water and Hydropower: Disputes over joint river-valley projects and shared water resources have frequently led to public perceptions that Nepal receives a raw deal.

The mistrust between the two countries are quite deep and many, not just superficial and few. The relation between Nepal and India is as bad as relation between Canada and US now, with the big ones bullying the much small ones, though both pairs had close relations before.

 

[Nimble]

View attachment 216926



bread and daughter?

So after Nepal’s constitutional amendments, can Madhesi people who obtained Nepalese citizenship by birth or naturalization now run for president of Nepal?

The answer is no...

Nepal still has a considerable degree of distrust toward you Indians.

Obviously no because every country will have some supreme position secured.... I never said that madheshis after taking citizenship can become anything they want.... even Nepali who gets citizenship in India can't become prime Minister of India... there's a limit.... point is USA Canada example is wrong in case of India Nepal example....

 

[Panda_Hi]

Obviously no because every country will have some supreme position secured.... I never said that madheshis after taking citizenship can become anything they want.... even Nepali who gets citizenship in India can't become prime Minister of India... there's a limit.... point is USA Canada example is wrong in case of India Nepal example....

The examples of the United States and Canada have nothing to do with me. You replied to the wrong person.

-----------------

Even Nepali who gets citizenship in India can't become prime Minister of India?

Yet India tried to interfere in Nepal’s constitutional amendments at the time, pushing for Madhesi people who obtained citizenship by birth or naturalization to have the right to become President of Nepal.

So your argument fails...

Your reply this time only further proves that India also has concerns about Nepal. It seems that this distrust goes both ways.