‘I want to cry’: Afghan medical students in Pakistan face expulsion fear

[El Sidd]

Very lively nation.

9 pages of discussion with diverse opinion and eager to form consensus.

 

[Master Chief]

The claim that “all Afghans are ungrateful and anti‑Pakistan” is factually incorrect, historically incomplete, and unfair to millions of Afghans who have lived peacefully, contributed economically, and maintained positive ties with Pakistan. Security concerns are real, but they don’t justify blanket judgments about an entire people.

Recently, I was invited by Afghani brother for Dinner and Pakistani retired Major sahab was also there.

You continue to misinterpret reality.

Kabul does not recognise Pakistani sovereignty. That individual Afghans are cordial, polite, and even good guests in Pakistan, is very much true. However, barring those who explicitly reject their own state policy in this regard (and there are plenty who do reject it for various reasons), the default assumption is justified. This is not blind discrimination but rather is a merit/evidence based assessment.

 

[The Sundance Kid]

Sure, not EVERY individual is problematic.

Still, better to just shut the door and be safe.