Imran Khan 3 years in solitary confinement

Criticize PTI all you want, that’s fair game in politics.
But saying KP had “zero development,” “record corruption,” or was “left to dogs” isn’t a serious argument. It’s what people fall back on when they stop looking at facts and start repeating whatever slogan feels good in the moment.

And this claim that “PTI has done nothing but suck up to TTP since 2013” that’s where the conversation really drifts into fiction. It’s the kind of thing people say when they’ve wandered so far from reality that they start sounding like Agent Smith glitching in the Matrix. At that point, it’s not a debate about governance anymore. It’s like you’ve slipped into an alternate universe where PTI is Hydra, a comic‑book villain, and every disagreement magically becomes “terrorism.”

That’s not political analysis.
That’s just storytelling, dramatic, emotional, and completely disconnected from how policy, security, or provincial governance actually works.
 
First provide the original document that is carbon dated and we'll go from there.

I mean Afghans wouldn't accept it anyways as it's not in our national interest.... but just for a bit of fun

Nobody's going to beg you to accept it. You will accept it weather you choose to or not. Sheer force has kept you weaklings in your place for almost a century and always will.
 
I’m open to holding a referendum in Afghanistan to see which provinces, if any, would want to join Pakistan. I’m fully aware that Pakistani establishment would oppose this idea. For the past 50+ years (after losing east Pakistan), they’ve repeatedly emphasized that Pakistan’s strength comes from the fact that they form the majority in both the military and the broader state structure. And this mindset is the same one you often see among certain upper‑class (Roman Elites) circles, a belief that they are inherently superior and entitled to look down on everyone else. This is the reason we lost East Pakistan.
I don’t think anyone from this forum ever had the opportunity to sit down and have a deep conversations with Bengali speaking Pakistani military personnel (now Bangladeshi). They felt (at least some of them) lack of trust, they were not promoted, and some cases (not all of them) treated as 2nd class.
This exactly how this elite class treating Karachi.

I am sorry but that is absurd. Just because someone has a complain, it does not mean it is valid.
Please try not to repeat lies, try reading some history.

I suggest the history of military enrolment from Bengal province into the British Indian army, especially the decades before independence. It is non-existent. Apparently there was a jump during World War two for obvious reasons but don't forget to look at the religious makeup and also the religious ratio between Hindus and Muslim especially with regards to officer class.

You can't create or promote soldiers when you have no Bengali soldiers. Pakistan army reduced it's requirements to ensure more Bengalis could join the armed forces. You cannot recreate an army overnight, it takes time, which is why despite 20 years of training and development by the best army America and best military alliance NATO, the Afghan army disappeared overnight, because it takes more then just training and handing someone a gun.

Even today people of East Punjab, that's the states of Punjab, Haryana, and Himachal Pradesh form the largest percentage in Indian armed forces, far above their proportion of population. It has been 80 years of actively trying to introduce other groups but still they have not been able to succeed. That's why in virtually every clip you see of indian military, you hear Punjabi being spoken in the background, or you'll see a Turban.
Pakistan period was 24 years, yet they achieved a lot regarding integration but you cannot have full change overnight.

While you're at it, check what percentage of top civil service was from East Bengal at independence in 1947? Almost non-existent. By 1971, there was a massive increase, not parity but getting closer. Again, a mere 24 years, during which time they were building new institution from scratch for the country in two separate halves, whilst dealing with a massive refugee population amount to about 25% of the population in West Pakistan and I think possibly 10% in the East Pakistan. Everything was given to India on a plate.

So those Bengali cries are just crocodile tears out of ignorance. There were issues but i am sick of these blown out of proportion constant crying by everyone, including the Bengalis. They did not turn Bangladesh into a land of milk and honey, if West Pakistan was draining so much then they should have had a glorious period without the burden of West Pakistan. In fact they did far worse.

For fair comparison, you can only compare 24 years with 24 years, that's till 1994. The 47-71 24 years with Pakistan cannot be compared till eternity.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top