'Indus Water Treaty Not feasible to maintain': India serves notice to Pakistan, seeks Modification.

[drkrn86]

And india had made it clear it no longer intends to abide by it. No one including the world Bank can enforce it if india decides to junk it.

Pakistan has the right to go to war. You can chose to exercise that right. But regardless of that, this treaty is no longer acceptable and will be abrogated or renegotiated.

Either way the good luck this unequal treaty will not live much longer.

Pakistan will start a war, may be on "X".
By the way, which countries will support pakistan in this. I am curoius to see.

 

[hydrabadi_arab]

We have started utilizing our share of water which is around 20℅ till now.

Sharing should be based on volume and not count(3:3). Indus briefly flows through India and we should be allowed to utilise it's water, not just Indus other rivers too. Pakistan should utilize it's share of water by building dams and irrigation system.

We have no control on rivers coming from China, if they plan to divert them there is nothing much we can do. The major river coming from China is Brahmaputra, but good point for us is most of the tributaries making it big are in India.

Like I said India already got more then they deserved. One exemple is how Indian sikhs woke up and stopped Yamna canal. There are international laws on rivers and its not the case of 50/50 share between states.

Gangus already used punjab water to irrigate Rajasthan. Now they wanted to divert water to Haryana before sikhs said enough is enough.

Good luck breaking international treaty, our army will finally have good reason to start war.

 

[drkrn86]

It will take enormous energy to transfer Indus waters to rest of India. It is not worth the energy - probably easier to desalinate sea water

Atleast for now, desalination is resource intense and costly for us. Lift irrigation schemes are definitely costly, but we always need to look into ROI.

NABARD - National Bank For Agriculture And Rural Development

www.nabard.org

This isn't much, but will give you an idea about what is to come.

 

[GatlingGun]

Like I said India already got more then they deserved. One exemple is how Indian sikhs woke up and stopped Yamna canal. There are international laws on rivers and its not the case of 50/50 share between states.

Gangus already used punjab water to irrigate Rajasthan. Now they wanted to divert water to Haryana before sikhs said enough is enough.

Good luck breaking international treaty, our army will finally have good reason to start war.

India deserves water in proportion to it's population 6/7th. We will send extra water we got from cancelling the treaty to Sikh Bros in our Punjab. Doing this we can shoot two birds with one stone. I bet Indian govt has same in the mind.

 

[drkrn86]

A treaty is mutually accepted agreement.
There is no concept of being fair or unfair.
If India feels it doesn't get it's rightful share, it will take necessary course of action.

 

[drkrn86]

You both are deluded, renege unilaterally on internationally brokered treaties and you will be seen as an unreliable partner.

Also big words try and threaten Paks water security and you will find out what will happen, your not dealing with Palestine here.

It's not what these two individuals think or want.
It really Doesn't matter if Pakistan considers us unreliable, we couldn't care much.
Pakistan should introspect and invest in things which improve their watter security rather than looking for free water.

 

[drkrn86]

How? 90% of indus rivers length is in Pakistan. India is lucky to have full control of 3 eastern rivers thanks to bastard dictator Ayub Khan who sold punjab water. 20% is 10% too much and India knows it, they have irrigated desert Rajasthan with our water.

Does India share 50/50 water with China?

1. Internet says 710 kms of nearly 3100 ms run in India. How did you come to 90%.
However it's logical to expect more share of water when majority river runs in your territory. There are many other factors to consider I assume before deciding share of water.

2. China doesn't have any water sharing treaty with any other country AFAIK.

 

[drkrn86]

India deserves water in proportion to it's population 6/7th. We will send extra water we got from cancelling the treaty to Sikh Bros in our Punjab. Doing this we can shoot two birds with one stone. I bet Indian govt has same in the mind.

Not sure, but the govt would send the water till Gujrat.
If the Govt can pull something like a major lift irrigation project on indus river, it becomes a boon for dry states of Rajasthan and Gujarat.

 

[hydrabadi_arab]

A treaty is mutually accepted agreement.
There is no concept of being fair or unfair.
If India feels it doesn't get it's rightful share, it will take necessary course of action.

India have been crying to get Pakistan water since I joined PDF. At the end they will only get what they agreed in 1960, water from 3 eastern rivers.

The rest is just statements BJP govt write to rally up their hindutva voter base.

Pakistan will ignore this political proposal. BJP keep their base happy. Nothing happens.

 

[drkrn86]

India have been crying to get Pakistan water since I joined PDF. At the end they will only get what they agreed in 1960, water from 3 eastern rivers.

The rest is just statements BJP govt write to rally up their hindutva voter base.

Pakistan will ignore this political proposal. BJP keep their base happy. Nothing happens.

It's not Pakistan water, It's Indus water. We have an equal right on it.
The same BJP kept It's word on A370.
Nothing happened.

 

[lightning f57]

Unreliable partner ? You think Pakistan is, After initiating wars multiple times?

It depends against whom we withdraw the treaty. You think civvies shed tears if police thrashes some pickpocket or mobile snatchers.

Maybe you failed to read properly this is an international brokered treaty, the world will see india not realisble.

Pakistan will start a war, may be on "X".
By the way, which countries will support pakistan in this. I am curoius to see.

See above, China will support for sure and the base of these rivers starts in China as well.

It's not what these two individuals think or want.
It really Doesn't matter if Pakistan considers us unreliable, we couldn't care much.
Pakistan should introspect and invest in things which improve their watter security rather than looking for free water.

International community will see that India doesn't stick to treaties.

Anyway let's see what modi and his rabid crew will do his been barking about this since 2016 he can keep barking.

 

[GatlingGun]

Maybe you failed to read properly this is an international brokered treaty, the world will see india not realisble.


See above, China will support for sure and the base of these rivers starts in China as well.


International community will see that India doesn't stick to treaties.

Anyway let's see what modi and his rabid crew will do his been barking about this since 2016 he can keep barking.

World will see India was too generous while disproportionately giving 80% to hostile nation like Pakistan , even a 50-50 deal would bring no sympathy for Pakistan.

China can block whatever they want. In the end Pakistan will get certain percentage of total flow. So you better pray that China doesn't do anything fancy.

 

[Areesh]

We'll let the experts decide how to do it,

Yup that is not for you to think

You just got a new lollypop from BJP to suck. Lets just focus on sucking it

 

[Areesh]

The same BJP kept It's word on A370.

Article 370 was a clause in Indian constitution which means nothing to Pakistan

In fact Pakistan changed status of GB despite India's protests years before India abrogated article 370

I don't know why you guys take changing your own constitution as some sort of act of bravado

 

[Areesh]

World will see India was too generous while disproportionately giving 80% to hostile nation like Pakistan , even a 50-50 deal would bring no sympathy for Pakistan.

China can block whatever they want. In the end Pakistan will get certain percentage of total flow. So you better pray that China doesn't do anything fancy.

And what are you to do with all the water of three rivers? Bhagwan Modi would drink all of it??

You low IQ morons are given new lollypop by BJP after recent continuous deaths of your security forces in IOK and as expected you started sucking without asking important questions