Russia-Ukraine War - News, Discussions & Updates

Status
Not open for further replies.
Getting into key positions that are not defended well does not require too many infantry.
For example it took 1 year for Russia to expel Ukr troops out of Kherson-Krynky and same is also true for Kursk region where after both Ukr counteroffensefies they managed to gain foothold there for a long time and only with NK support they were somewhat expelled now.
They were completely driven out so much that they already entered Sumy and yes with the support of the DPRK which sent 10 thousand fighters, most of them were KPA units supposedly special forces of the XI Corps. They are elite light infantry, almost special forces, they have their pick in terms of who can enter, they receive advanced training compared to the rest of the KPA, and their mission in a war is exactly what they were supposedly tasked with doing at Kursk: breaking through prepared defenses on foot. This does not make the Kurk issue a Russian failure when in reality even Ukrainian commanders are resigning due to incompetent strategies of the Ukrainian command, which includes Kursk, whose number of deaths and material losses were enormous for the objective they wanted, it is not surprising that Putin does not kill Zelensky.
Now Ru has much less air defence in Crimea for example and it will be harder to gain an area like Krynky back for example providing there with enough air support. While all Ru soldiers focus on Zaporijia-Pokrovsk sector it would be a nice time for other Ukr incursions.
This is exactly the kind of maneuver the Russians expect and want from the Ukrainians. I don’t doubt that they will do it because the comedian who is leading the war on the Ukrainian side is a PR agent and wants to make the war his main TV show. Ukraine has never won a single battle while it has been on the offensive since November 2022, do you really think that this will change anything?
Last time Ukr made incursion into Kherson after huge losses and Russian high focus in other areas.
If Putin is calling the shots either he cannot translate his Judo skills into real life or there is something else going on behind the scenes. If generals are calling the shots then there should be some upgrade on them about getting over ww2 style planning.
Last time Ukraine had invaded Kherson with huge losses but with mobilized personnel and its units with TO&E above 60-70%, now this maximum is no more than 50% in all its battalions, whose main deficiency is chronic understaffing. I think you are being fed by Ukrainian propaganda, because both sides suffer from the same problem: there is no breakthrough because it is simply not possible.
If a boxer throws a punch and eats a counter punch he wont throw the same punch over and over again. He would get into defense adapt and strike different areas. If he takes the same punch over and over again without improvement the viewers may rightfully think the match might be sold to the oppposing side from the top management.
Good analogy but useless considering we are seeing two Soviet armies fighting each other.
How do Russians think of dismantling Ukranian drone-guided integrated fire system. Perhaps not by sending 2x soldiers to attack the same area over and over again or is it? It is not ww2 now everything is seen from above and everything is guided to a degree so human wave strategy seems to be a self sabotage on the long run.
You simply do not know the reality of the ground nor the Recon Fires Complex that keeps both under constant surveillance and continuous attack preventing any advance that explores areas after the attempted penetration. By the way, the Ukrainians made the same type of attack that the Russians are making in the failed counteroffensive in 2023 in the first days after the initial armor losses in the Robotyne axis. Do you call these human wave attacks too?
Russia had to adapt its own drone-guided integrated fire system on par with Ukraine while using manpower as a defensive resource holding the captured areas and focus more on air dominance before ground attack starts.
Russia has been using its Recon Fires Complex since the beginning of the war, but Ukraine already had its system ready and operational, unlike the Russians who, in addition to expanding the use of the system, began to deploy drones that began to be part of the Russian system, something that the Ukrainians had already done even before starting the war. The year 2022 was the year in which the Russians tried to advance while their Recon Fires Complex had not even reached its majority, while the year 2023 was when we saw that ISTAR began to improve, which ended up culminating in the failed Ukrainian counteroffensive in the summer of 2023.
Only after you control the air that is flying freely over eastern Ukrine then you can degrade Ukr recon-fire complex continiously and penetrate with wave attacks from weakened positions. Otherwise it is a slow suicide demilitarizing yourself creating openings for Ukr counter attacks.
The Russians have neither the training nor the skills, much less the experience, to conduct SEAD/DEAD operations that would allow the VKS to control the air, yet drones are still part of the recon fires complex and fighters will not be of much use in degrading FPV/DJ capabilities unless they start hunting each component of the recon firex complex individually or collectively, both sides are incapable of doing either of the two that would allow them to permanently degrade the other's recon firex complex.

Dude, study up on the "bite and hold" strategy, both sides have been doing it since 2023.
 
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
 
I guess zooming in on maps of large countries is needed sometimes
If one side had considerable achievements there would be no need to zoom. War is entering it's 4th year and they are still at a stalemate. Both side losing considerable amount of gear and manpower. One would think a war of attrition would favor Russia. However, Ukraine still manages to compansate for it's loses (same goes for Russia). In my eyes, neither side has the upper hand.

Like i said, stop assuming things. You don't have to pick a side and root for it in every conflict as it would cloud your judgement.
 
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
 
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
 
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
 
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
 
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
 
If one side had considerable achievements there would be no need to zoom. War is entering it's 4th year and they are still at a stalemate. Both side losing considerable amount of gear and manpower. One would think a war of attrition would favor Russia. However, Ukraine still manages to compansate for it's loses (same goes for Russia). In my eyes, neither side has the upper hand.

Like i said, stop assuming things. You don't have to pick a side and root for it in every conflict as it would cloud your judgement.
one side losing 20% of their territory and 25% of their people doesn't seem like a stalemate
 
one side losing 20% of their territory and 25% of their people doesn't seem like a stalemate
I'm talking about winning the war. Check Ukrainian troop numbers by years.

Anyway, enough wasting of my time, keep cheering whatever side you want to cheer...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top