The Case for Pakistan as a Civilizational State

[r3alist]

9:00 onwards, uncle has lost it.

"Taxila", "Panini", "Chanakiya" - are Pakistani by default. This is simple geography. No independent, unified "India" existed that covered Pakistani lands at any time in history. If he is subtly pushing the Mauryan Empire onto us, how exactly did the Mauryans unify their empire? Was it possibly by the same sword that this moron curses out Mughals and British for in this same video?

If he accepts forcible imperial unification by Grandfather Maurya, (thus bringing Indus lands - briefly - under control of a centralised empire, whose capital was thousands of miles away btw), then he can hardly complain when anyone else brings Indus lands under their yoke.

Amateurish pseudo-historical ranting, as is their wont.

If Imperial borders are an issue then Indias borders are also an issue and Pakistan wanted more land, ergo more ivc archaeological sites


This guy is anti woke anti dei when it comes to African descent people

The simple consistent rebuttal is as follows, this is archaeology not communal politics inserted into archaeology

If that's the game for you, get out the discussion , you are in bad faith and poisoning the academic pursuit

Not much more to say to these guys, the more you say sometimes the more rope they grab

 

[Ali_Baba]

By far the best walk around of the site ever, I watched this last night and I learnt a lot from it. I recommend all to watch this if you have not been to the site at all.