India Economy Thread

[Mighty_Dragon_Strike]

Read the article for absolute numbers, it's equal to what Pakistan sells in whole FY.

if it has come down to comparison with PAk...

then, well I rest my case!

your soul just died and you sold your soul to the highest bidder!
(your eyes cant see, how growth can even happen in a dead economy, which was the case in great financial collapse!)

Further, as I said, had there been so many 'advances' these politicians would have spoken themselves!

increase in two wheelers, could be due to shrinkage of middle class, not increase in middle class!

 

[GatlingGunZ]

if it has come down to comparison with PAk...

then, well I rest my case!

your soul just died and you sold your soul to the highest bidder!
(your eyes cant see, how growth can even happen in a dead economy, which was the case in great financial collapse!)

Further, as I said, had there been so many 'advances' these politicians would have spoken themselves!

increase in two wheelers, could be due to shrinkage of middle class, not increase in middle class!

I mean you can go and get financing stats and % of delinquency/failure rate from some chatgpt.
25 million annually is not some bubble. Kindly give your theory how two wheeler sales is shrinkage in middle-class? You think rich people work in factory floors ?

 

[Vikramaditya1]

I just point out subtle and nuanced unnoticed differences

not disputing anything!

after all, had there been so much 'advances', there would have not much to hide behind and politicians would have let us known!


speculation kills growth!

You showed us nothing though. You made statements without any data. I don't understand what you mean by speculation because we don't speculate GDP growth.

 

[Mighty_Dragon_Strike]

You showed us nothing though. You made statements without any data. I don't understand what you

I mean you can go and get financing stats and % of delinquency/failure rate from some chatgpt.
25 million annually is not some bubble. Kindly give your theory how two wheeler sales is shrinkage in middle-class? You think rich people work in factory floors ?

mean by speculation because we don't speculate GDP growth.

simple question, whats your CPI, whats your inflation, whats your national debt?

whats your trade imbalances with top 5?

I dont think, much remains to debate here!

further, re. floor workers, whats use of such workers, if there no increase manufacturing capacity!

further, claim has come on your side, onus is on you to show!

I m just asking, whats glaringly obvious to any sane mind!

if you dont agree, thats your choice!


if am wrong, CPI, inflation ect etc, would prove me right!

are you ready to produce these numbers?!

 

[GatlingGunZ]

simple question, whats your CPI, whats your inflation, whats your national debt?

whats your trade imbalances with top 5?

I dont think, much remains to debate here!

further, re. floor workers, whats use of such workers, if there no increase manufacturing capacity!

further, claim has come on your side, onus is on you to show!

I m just asking, whats glaringly obvious to any sane mind!

if you dont agree, thats your choice!


if am wrong, CPI, inflation ect etc, would prove me right!

are you ready to produce these numbers?!

How onus is on us?
You are making a hypothesis so bring your own data to refute India's economic growth data.
Tell us what are the anomalies which make you believe that Indian middle class is shrinking ?

 

[Mighty_Dragon_Strike]

How onus is on me?
You are making a hypothesis so bring your own data to refute India's economic growth data.
Tell us what are the anomalies which make you believe that Indian middle class is shrinking ?

bro, India is growing with 10% growth

i was wrong, I was making things up!

I was wrong, India has bough gold and has huge gold reserves with many manufacturing capacity that is unmatched by any country!

happy now!

now please buzz off and learn to have an educated debate!

 

[NeptunesVortex]

if it has come down to comparison with PAk...

then, well I rest my case!

your soul just died and you sold your soul to the highest bidder!
(your eyes cant see, how growth can even happen in a dead economy, which was the case in great financial collapse!)

Further, as I said, had there been so many 'advances' these politicians would have spoken themselves!

increase in two wheelers, could be due to shrinkage of middle class, not increase in middle class!

India's exports of goods and services grew 12% YoY in real terms in Q1 FY27 while imports actually degrew by 1.1%. That's from the GDP data itself.

 

[Mighty_Dragon_Strike]

India's exports of goods and services grew 12% YoY in real terms in Q1 FY27 while imports actually degrew by 1.1%. That's from the GDP data itself.

sir, I have given up

Indian exports are now at sky high, and are now about to reach new galaxy!


happy now!
great bharat mata!

happy now?!

 

[GatlingGunZ]

sir, I have given up

Indian exports are now at sky high, and are now about to reach new galaxy!


happy now!
great bharat mata!

happy now?!

Don't be disheartened. Just post that data using which you were writing off Indian economic growth few minutes back. I bet you had it, otherwise you wouldn't have been making those claims.

 

[Mighty_Dragon_Strike]

Don't be disheartened. Just post that data using which you were writing off Indian economic growth few minutes back. I bet you had it, otherwise you wouldn't have been making those claims.

good, fireworks you win!


I was wrong, not much remains now, bye!

go enjoy 10% growth rate!

 

[Thinking_Hard]

You guys are still doing it. You can fake many things but not export and import data. Or taxes. You also can't fake actual consumption.

Anyways, we might hit 1 trillion USD export this year (goods and services). Ofcourse good import is out of control.

 

[CallSignMaverick]

 

[Vikramaditya1]

simple question, whats your CPI, whats your inflation, whats your national debt?

whats your trade imbalances with top 5?

I dont think, much remains to debate here!

further, re. floor workers, whats use of such workers, if there no increase manufacturing capacity!

further, claim has come on your side, onus is on you to show!

I m just asking, whats glaringly obvious to any sane mind!

if you dont agree, thats your choice!


if am wrong, CPI, inflation ect etc, would prove me right!

are you ready to produce these numbers?!

Latest CPI inflation: 4.82% YoY in August. Slightly over the RBI target of 4%.

Debt $2.4 Trillion, this isn't majorly affecting our growth rate. There is nothing to debate because you haven't produced anything that's worth debating about.

As for floor workers issue you invented, you first need to establish that manufacturing capacity isn't increasing. Current evidence points the other way, real manufacturing GVA grew 9.2% YoY in Q1 this year.

Yeah you're proven right. Surely....

 

[Mighty_Dragon_Strike]

Latest CPI inflation: 4.82% YoY in August. Slightly over the RBI target of 4%.

Debt $2.4 Trillion, this isn't majorly affecting our growth rate. There is nothing to debate because you haven't produced anything that's worth debating about.

As for floor workers issue you invented, you first need to establish that manufacturing capacity isn't increasing. Current evidence points the other way, real manufacturing GVA grew 9.2% YoY in Q1 this year.

Yeah you're proven right. Surely....

I very well could!

dont want to, inflation is a percentage figure, it is a relative figure!

not used like you have chosen to use in a single, without any context!

I have said before, growth is 10% hurrah, go enjoy!

dont worry what I say!

 

[Vikramaditya1]

I very well could!

dont want to, inflation is a percentage figure, it is a relative figure!

not used like you have chosen to use in a single, without any context!

I have said before, growth is 10% hurrah, go enjoy!

dont worry what I say!

All of a sudden huh? You're the one who challenged me for those numbers. CPI, Debt yada yada yada.
What were you expecting?

You argued numbers don't make sense, they make perfect sense to everyone who knows basic economics.

If your argument is that India's reported real growth is unsustainable or misleading, make that argument and show the mechanism. Inflation, public debt and a trade deficit don't become evidence of that merely by listing them.