Opinion Piece- Beyond Partition: Imagining an India-Pakistan Friendship

Ultimately, my question remains: must we resolve every grievance, establish trust and reconcile our historical differences before we can even begin to establish a functional relationship?

It is not the future or existing governments of india that need to apologize, it is the common street indian who believed lies about Pakistanis and Pakistan, who intentionally jumped the band wagon of "Ghar may ghuss kay mary gay".

Establishing anything prior to that realisation is fruitless, after all it wasn't us attacking the Sri Lankan cricket team, it weren't us refusing to play with each other, it weren't us bragging about our money and we do not want you, the common street indian needs to first apologize for refusing to shake hands and insults. Everything else comes after this.


Or can we attempt to do some of those things alongside one another?

Should Pakistanis be hypocrite? Is that the question you are asking us?
 
Not in the slightest. They made a diplomatic response while in position of power (same as a Mod) as expected of them, you ask Modi the same question and he will say the same thing "Dialogue". An average India would want nothing to do with Pakistan except maybe some odd fellas who still see some bhaichara (expect the same on that side as well).

There is simply no benefit for either of us to have a relationship. Our trade partners are sitting thousands of miles away and neither of us are dependent on each other for trade. Basically we can have zero trade and be just fine. You don't produce things we need desperately, we don't produce things you need desperately. So I don't know why there is a great need for reapproachment. We have our disagreements and let it continue. We are not agreeing to your demands for plebiscite in Kashmir, so fundamentally the Indo - Pak reapproachment is a non starter.
I think you're making an interesting distinction between diplomatic rhetoric and genuine public sentiment. Fair enough, political statements advocating dialogue don't necessarily translate into a genuine appetite for rapprochement.

But I think we're approaching this from different starting points.

I'm not particularly interested in making a case for why India and Pakistan must become friends, or in convincing anyone that closer relations are necessarily desirable.

What I'm interested in is stepping back for a moment and examining where we've arrived, how we've arrived here, and what perpetuating this state of affairs has cost both societies.

We have lived with this relationship for generations. Its consequences aren't confined to diplomatic posturing or military expenditure. They permeate the lives of ordinary people and shape the circumstances inherited by future generations.

We've chosen, for whatever reasons, to sustain this arrangement. Perhaps there are compelling reasons for doing so. But have we ever really stopped to examine the costs, consider the alternatives and ask ourselves whether this is how we want the next generation to inherit the relationship?

That's really the thought experiment. I'm not particularly invested in convincing everyone of an alternative. I'm interested in having the conversation, including hearing why others believe the status quo is preferable.
 
It is not the future or existing governments of india that need to apologize, it is the common street indian who believed lies about Pakistanis and Pakistan, who intentionally jumped the band wagon of "Ghar may ghuss kay mary gay".

Establishing anything prior to that realisation is fruitless, after all it wasn't us attacking the Sri Lankan cricket team, it weren't us refusing to play with each other, it weren't us bragging about our money and we do not want you, the common street indian needs to first apologize for refusing to shake hands and insults. Everything else comes after this.




Should Pakistanis be hypocrite? Is that the question you are asking us?
If I'm understanding you correctly, your position is that:

- It isn't sufficient for the Indian government to change its approach or for diplomatic channels to reopen.
- Ordinary Indians who participated in, endorsed or encouraged hostility towards Pakistan and Pakistanis must first acknowledge their conduct and apologise.
- This acknowledgement must precede any meaningful attempt at normalisation. Anything less would amount to hypocrisy on Pakistan's part.

I fundamentally disagree with making this a precondition. You're effectively making the actions and attitudes of an entire population the determining factor in whether two countries can move forward. This isn't a condition that can realistically be fulfilled, and certainly not one that can be meaningfully imposed on an entire society.

The practical consequence is that normalisation becomes indefinitely conditional on an act of collective contrition that may never materialise. In effect, no change in government, no change in policy and no improvement in circumstances would be sufficient unless this prior condition was met.

And this brings me back to the thought experiment I'm proposing. Let's put aside, for a moment, whether we believe rapprochement is desirable or even achievable.

Let's examine two scenarios on their respective merits: continuing along the trajectory we've followed for decades, and exploring what an alternative relationship might look like without making the resolution of every historical grievance a prerequisite.

What are the respective costs, benefits, risks and opportunities foregone? What does each scenario mean for the ordinary Indian and Pakistani today, and for the generations that follow?

I'm not asking anyone to arrive at a predetermined conclusion. I'm suggesting that both possibilities deserve the same degree of scrutiny.
 
If I'm understanding you correctly, your position is that:

- It isn't sufficient for the Indian government to change its approach or for diplomatic channels to reopen.
- Ordinary Indians who participated in, endorsed or encouraged hostility towards Pakistan and Pakistanis must first acknowledge their conduct and apologise.
- This acknowledgement must precede any meaningful attempt at normalisation. Anything less would amount to hypocrisy on Pakistan's part.

I fundamentally disagree with making this a precondition. You're effectively making the actions and attitudes of an entire population the determining factor in whether two countries can move forward. This isn't a condition that can realistically be fulfilled, and certainly not one that can be meaningfully imposed on an entire society.

The practical consequence is that normalisation becomes indefinitely conditional on an act of collective contrition that may never materialise. In effect, no change in government, no change in policy and no improvement in circumstances would be sufficient unless this prior condition was met.

And this brings me back to the thought experiment I'm proposing. Let's put aside, for a moment, whether we believe rapprochement is desirable or even achievable.

Let's examine two scenarios on their respective merits: continuing along the trajectory we've followed for decades, and exploring what an alternative relationship might look like without making the resolution of every historical grievance a prerequisite.

What are the respective costs, benefits, risks and opportunities foregone? What does each scenario mean for the ordinary Indian and Pakistani today, and for the generations that follow?

I'm not asking anyone to arrive at a predetermined conclusion. I'm suggesting that both possibilities deserve the same degree of scrutiny.

indian state carried out the will of its people in 2019 and 2025 and killed common Pakistanis including children (even if I ignore their support for terrorist entities against Pakistan), how do you expect Pakistanis to reconcile this with what you are proposing now? Forget? Why? indians already believe they have nothing to gain from Pakistan, and Pakistan has survived without having relations at all with india.

We have witnessed nothing but pure hatred out of india for more than a decade. Big slogans, childish policies, stupid statements. The indian child born 14 years ago knows nothing about Pakistan but this only. That is an ordinary indian, and I want the 14 years old Pakistani child not to forget all this.

You had the upper hand in relations, you were able to subtly belittle us, now that is gone, if you are curious to know what is foregone. Now, you have your partners and we have ours. Lets limit this circus to the Wagha border and not beyond, Aman ka tamasha candle should only be relit with apology first. Trust is earned not granted.
 
If Pak and India had full economic relations (Not impossible, even rivals like China and Japan do), the implications for both would be immense. For Pakistan we could import cheaper Indian agri and industrial products and export our own products to 1. 4 Billion. Indians companies would have access to another 250 million consumers and direct land access to Iran and Europe and the Gulf.
 
indian state carried out the will of its people in 2019 and 2025 and killed common Pakistanis including children (even if I ignore their support for terrorist entities against Pakistan), how do you expect Pakistanis to reconcile this with what you are proposing now? Forget? Why? indians already believe they have nothing to gain from Pakistan, and Pakistan has survived without having relations at all with india.

We have witnessed nothing but pure hatred out of india for more than a decade. Big slogans, childish policies, stupid statements. The indian child born 14 years ago knows nothing about Pakistan but this only. That is an ordinary indian, and I want the 14 years old Pakistani child not to forget all this.

You had the upper hand in relations, you were able to subtly belittle us, now that is gone, if you are curious to know what is foregone. Now, you have your partners and we have ours. Lets limit this circus to the Wagha border and not beyond, Aman ka tamasha candle should only be relit with apology first. Trust is earned not granted.
I think I understand your position. You've experienced the hostility of the last 14 years, believe ordinary Indians share responsibility for it, want that experience preserved in the national memory of future generations, see little benefit in bilateral relations, and consider an apology a prerequisite for any rapprochement.

But here's where I struggle with this reasoning.

I could make almost the exact same argument from the Indian side, and I suspect you could anticipate what that would look like. We have our own catalogue of grievances, casualties, attacks, humiliations and historical grievances. We can point to our own experiences, insist that Pakistanis acknowledge them, demand apologies and conclude that there is little to be gained from engaging with a country that has caused us so much grief.

And so what? We arrive at precisely where we are today, with each side's grievances serving as justification for the other's continued estrangement.

I also find your interpretation of my position rather curious. You seem to assume that my interest in exploring better relations stems from a belief that Pakistan is ascending, India is losing ground, and that this somehow creates an opportunity or incentive to seek friendship. I don't see the connection. My position would be exactly the same irrespective of which country was economically, militarily or geopolitically ascendant.

I'm not making a case for friendship because Pakistan needs something from India, or because India needs something from Pakistan. I'm questioning the value of perpetuating an adversarial relationship simply because both sides have convinced themselves that the other deserves nothing better.

The question I'm exploring is what this arrangement has cost us, what continuing it will cost us, and what an alternative might look like.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Pakistan Defence Latest

Country Watch Latest

Back
Top