If Pak and India had full economic relations (Not impossible, even rivals like China and Japan do), the implications for both would be immense. For Pakistan we could import cheaper Indian agri and industrial products and export our own products to 1. 4 Billion. Indians companies would have access to another 250 million consumers and direct land access to Iran and Europe and the Gulf.
There's quite a bit to unpack here, both in terms of the opportunities and the potential complications.
For Pakistan, access to the Indian market could create opportunities for textiles, agricultural produce, pharmaceuticals, surgical instruments and other manufactured goods. Cheaper Indian industrial inputs and agricultural products could also benefit Pakistani consumers and manufacturers.
For India, access to a neighbouring market of 250 million people offers its own commercial opportunities. Indian manufacturers, pharmaceutical companies, agricultural businesses and service providers would gain another sizeable consumer base. Overland connectivity through Pakistan could also open up trade routes towards Iran, the Gulf and potentially Europe.
There are, however, some important considerations.
The two economies aren't on equal footing. India's industrial base, capital availability and manufacturing scale are considerably larger. Unrestricted access to each other's markets could expose Pakistani manufacturers to competition they may struggle to withstand. Some domestic industries could contract, businesses could close and employment could be affected. There could also be concerns around trade imbalances and increasing dependence on Indian imports.
India would have its own considerations, including security, transit arrangements, regulatory barriers and the political reliability of cross-border commercial relationships.
There would also be adjustment costs on both sides. Trade liberalisation isn't simply a matter of opening borders; it requires customs integration, banking arrangements, standards harmonisation, transport infrastructure and mechanisms to address disputes and protect vulnerable industries.
I'm not suggesting these complications outweigh the potential benefits. Equally, I'm not suggesting that the benefits automatically justify unrestricted free trade.
But I do think there's an interesting economic proposition here. What would a phased opening of trade look like? Which sectors would benefit, which would be exposed, and what safeguards would each country need?
It would be interesting to actually examine the possibilities rather than simply assume that either the benefits or the costs are self-evident.