16 years old Bangladeshi Hindu girl killed by BSF

[Raj-Hindustani]

2Not allowed and killing a 13 years old girl for that are two different things.

Yeah, you meant in the mid night - they checked the identity and knew that age and then killed her?

Well - whatever you believe - in mid night if anyone try to cross illegally our borders - should be killed... Does not matter who is the one

 

[LeonBlack08]

By crossing international border illegally?

Sorry not allowed..

No one is claiming it is allowed.

What we are saying is you can apprehend instead of killing a human being. In this case the victim being a child. BGB has many cases of apprehending and then deporting the Indian nationals. Why can't BSF do the same?

 

[Al-Zakir]

No one is claiming it is allowed.

What we are saying is you can apprehend instead of killing a human being. In this case the victim being a child. BGB has many cases of apprehending and then deporting the Indian nationals. Why can't BSF do the same?

You are wasting your time.
Hindu fundamentalist believe that when they kill a Muslim, its same as one cow equal good deed.

 

[LeonBlack08]

You are wasting your time.
Hindu fundamentalist believe that when they kill a Muslim, its same as one cow equal good deed.

I know Bhai, was just hoping this was a rational human being.

 

[Raj-Hindustani]

You are wasting your time.
Hindu fundamentalist believe that when they kill a Muslim, its same as one cow equal good deed.

Did you miss the title - she was Hindu.

Last time I remember, the same bsf returned the Pakistani girl when she by mistakely crossed the border. Even indian girl crossed the border by mistakely... And they returned safely.

But crossing in midnight - and specific you don't know if they are armed or smugglers or attackers...

Army is not paid off to welcome them with sweets..

 

[UKBengali]

Did you miss the title - she was Hindu.

Last time I remember, the same bsf returned the Pakistani girl when she by mistakely crossed the border. Even indian girl crossed the border by mistakely... And they returned safely.

But crossing in midnight - and specific you don't know if they are armed or smugglers or attackers...

Army is not paid off to welcome them with sweets..

You cannot shoot someone on a "maybe".

That is not the way it works in life buddy.

Unless they are clearly identified as an imminent threat the right course of action is to try to make an arrest and then deport.

If BGB can do it, then why cannot BSF? It seems that this is the actions of a weak and insecure state than anything else.

India has serious issues if it cannot deal with illegals that cross the border apart from shoot on sight policy.

 

[Raj-Hindustani]

You cannot shoot someone on a "maybe".

That is not the way it works in life buddy.

Unless they are clearly identified as an imminent threat the right course of action is to try to make an arrest and then deport.

If BGB can do it, then why cannot BSF? It seems that this is the actions of a weak and insecure state than anything else.

India has serious issues if it cannot deal with illegals that cross the border apart from shoot on sight policy.

This does not apply at international borders, especially when someone crosses the border illegally at midnight.

This is all about the message - if a few incidents happen, people usually will not try something to cross the border illegally.

No doubt that it is a sad incident but again "you would not cross the borders if you knew that you might be killed".....

Even if an Indian is killed by the Pakistani or Bangladeshi army while crossing illegally in mid-night - I will support Pakistan or Bangladeshi army on those cases as well.

 

[UKBengali]

This does not apply at international borders, especially when someone crosses the border illegally at midnight.

This is all about the message - if a few incidents happen, people usually will not try something to cross the border illegally.

No doubt that it is a sad incident but again "you would not cross the borders if you knew that you might be killed".....

Even if an Indian is killed by the Pakistani or Bangladeshi army while crossing illegally in mid-night - I will support Pakistan or Bangladeshi army on those cases as well.

Neither BD or Pakistan are inhumane enough to shoot illegals that cross their border illegally.

It is not necessary and achieves sweet zero. Arresting and deportation is adequate and there is barely any cross border infiltration apart from a few smugglers that India itself created by banning beef exports to BD.

It is only done by crazy regimes like N Korea. All other instances are usually when there is an active war like between KSA and Yemen. KSA did shoot hundreds of Somalis back in 2022 but that was to stop mass illegal immigration, although that was not of course correct.

 

[Al-Zakir]

Did you miss the title - she was Hindu.

Last time I remember, the same bsf returned the Pakistani girl when she by mistakely crossed the border. Even indian girl crossed the border by mistakely... And they returned safely.

But crossing in midnight - and specific you don't know if they are armed or smugglers or attackers...

Army is not paid off to welcome them with sweets..

I didn't.

You see, BSF didn't know she was Hindu. If they knew, they wouldn't kill her rather they would have use her for spreading propaganda that Hindus aren't safe in Bd.

Pakistan is not Bd because they shoot right back at you.

We will do same in near future. BDR is coming back. Stay tuned.

 

[Raj-Hindustani]

I didn't.

You see, BSF didn't know she was Hindu. If they knew, they wouldn't kill her rather they would have use her for spreading propaganda that Hindus aren't safe in Bd.

Pakistan is not Bd because they shoot right back at you.

We will do same in near future. BDR is coming back. Stay tuned.

Seriously man! People just want to do criticism..

At mid night - I will repeat it again anyone crossing the international border Illegally... Only people who wants to do criticism about that country will to criticism.... Rest will understand it.... What is right or wrong..

Anyday or time BDR can come if they....

Best example is - by two wheeler, coming from the wrong direction in a highway and accident happened with a car.... And people started saying that car guys purposely killed those two wheelers... I agreed that there is a possibility mistake from the car driver but you can't justify what two wheeler person did it.

 

[LeonBlack08]

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Yunus describes border killings by BSF as 'callousness'​

Chief Adviser Muhammad Yunus has condemned border killings of Bangladeshis by India's Border Security Force, describing it as callousness and insisting they must stop because killing is no solution.

In an interview with India's state-owned news agency the Press Trust of India, or PTI, at his official residence in Dhaka, he also said the interim government would pursue ways to resolve differences over the long-pending Teesta water sharing treaty with India, as delaying it for years serves no purpose for either nation.

Speaking about the contentious issue of border killings, Yunus condemned it and said killing is not a solution to dealing with anything.

"Killing someone is not a solution, as there are legal ways to deal with this. There has to be a ground mechanism and legal procedure to handle it. This is a one-sided thing. No one is crossing the border to capture your country; those who are being killed by shooting are just couriers. This is callousness. This has to stop," he said.

Yunus describes border killings by BSF as 'callousness'

Chief Adviser Muhammad Yunus has condemned border killings of Bangladeshis by India's Border Security Force, describing it as callousness

www.thedailystar.net

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

What a change in approach compared to the Hasina regime, with its submissive posture. This is what it means to be truly independent!

 

[itsanufy]

BSF is very vigilant now. Even Indians are allowed to go for farming over the wired fence with BSF escorting them.
I am sure there is strict instruction from Delhi to stop any infiltration by any means.

 

[AjayGhatak]

According to Porendra Das, Swarna and her mother had attempted to cross into India illegally to visit his eldest son, who lives in Tripura.

They were aided by two local brokers. Around 9pm on Sunday, as they reached the fence on the Indian side, BSF personnel opened fire, killing Swarna instantly. Swarna’s mother narrowly escaped the gunfire."

If this is the case, BSF is right to use lethal force. Who knows why they were entering and what their motives were. Any illegal crossing is a threat.

 

[AjayGhatak]

What we are saying is you can apprehend instead of killing a human being. In this case the victim being a child. BGB has many cases of apprehending and then deporting the Indian nationals. Why can't BSF do the same?

How do you know those crossing the borders are not carrying weapons? I heard cattle smugglers are often armed.

 

[AjayGhatak]

You cannot shoot someone on a "maybe".

That is not the way it works in life buddy.

Huh? Have you ever seen how police in USA works?

They do not take chances and shoot first! Because you never know if the guy you are dealing with is armed or not.

Any party entering illegally could be anything. Armed militants, smugglers etc. You try to stop them and get closer and they shoot you.