Technically I have no issue with Tribalism as per say, my problem is that when people misuse or abuse tribal ties to harbor terrorism, you want to be proud of your tribe and race be my guest, Allah said in Quran we have made you in Tribes so you can identify one another, there is not much more about it, Islam is something to be proud of and Later being a Pakistan, if you hate the country has no given you anything by all means do hate your country and leave if you have better opportunities in a different country, no one is stopping people. But when you live in Pakistan, and then Harbor terrorists and elements that cause harm to not only your state but its innocent civilians and kids, who have nothing to do with military operations or anything that's when my problem begins, and when people do nothing to even address the problem rather than just keep beating around the bush, point the discussion in random totally non relevant directions that's when i know that people are doing BS.
People have issues, everywhere in Pakistan, I can take you to places in Karachi where people are living over a literally sewerage canal or aka Naala, there are kids who grow up in poverty and never see inside of a school, but they grow up to become electricians or plumbers or labors not terrorists or join internationally recognized terrorists groups or carry loads and loads of explosive to kill innocent civilians.
For far too long Tribalism has kept people from being civilized, you can't just make schools and shopping malls and hope that people will change, people only change when they realize they have a problem and its needs to be fixed, unfortunately we have 2 states which doesn't see any issues within its own social ranks rather they blame everyone else for their misery but themselves.
I'd say, this is very boxed and shallow approach.
this the reason of our mess.
let me ask you a very frank question.
if you are world's leading physicist or tax professional or tax advisor or economist who has worked in IMF for 35 years....how should you approach this problem?
current way (adopted by these so called professionals like zaidis', haque, khaqans, Mr. Black Hole physics!)
there is no way to resolve this problem unless military gives away powers!
now, my questions to you and so called professionals is:
1. in China, there was a social cohesion issue in the society, likes of which world had never seen before, they solved that without democracy!
2. fully tribal societies like Vietnam managed to defeat the USA
3. Japan found its feet from the worst feudalism in the world!
how come, all of that is possible, in such societies, science was virtually non-existent then, how come they managed to come up!
reason:
in this world, best finance professionals are physicists, chemists, watch makers, and diamond jewelers. Why is that?
bec. problem solving requires basic understanding of the inherent issues found at atomic core, which can only be understood if one is trained to think like that
solution:
ask your best physicist and chemists, to fix:
1. the economy 2. social cohesion
in those tribal belts. Ask them to do research and do pilot projects to improve each District or Division one by one. Frankly, if any of these so called professionals says no, throw them out of the country!
I found your post, honestly, of very low intellect (which I dont expect from you), that is the problem with living in cities
