You are proving my point with every reply. I never supported 28 provinces or any random map. I said smaller administrative units are worth discussing. But cultists heard something not coming from IK and immediately started screaming "establishment project."
1- You wanna start throwing around cultists and IK yet again while I never mentioned him.
2- It's not about you my man. It's what about federal ministers and everyone else in power says.
Get that phobia out of your mind dude...the world doesn't revolve around IK or PTI.
First you demand parliamentary debate, then declare the parliament a sham before any bill even reaches it. You reject the proposal, the person proposing it and the constitutional forum which must decide it.
Bingo. You phrase the exact same thing as me, but then deduce the absolute worst conclusion from it. Now you understand the problem? If the forum for deciding these matters itself is tainted, then how do you expect everyone to blindly abide by whatever they decide and how do you ensure whatever is happening is for the best interest of the people? Especially since the track record is shit.
It's like going to a corrupt judge who takes money from the local thug, and then go ahead and entrusting him with your safety.
So what exactly do you want, other than IK personally coming out of jail and announcing it?
Where did I say that? Unlike you I do not see IK everywhere I look. It's understandable though, happens when you need to create a boogeyman for your failures.
Yes, proper homework is required . Population, geography, revenue, resources and administrative cost must all be considered. If they present a stupid map without this, reject it. But calling the whole concept useless before seeing any actual plan is not critical thinking,
So where is the plan? Where will it come? Who will see it? Who will draft it?
Or will we see it 20 minutes before it is presented in the assembly for voting? And the committee members will be given different drafts, or will they be given secret drafts? You do know all this has happened before, right?
What kind of stockholm syndrome are you in?
Of who exactly? Who am I worshipping by bringing about a valid critique of something the current government/dictator proposed?
Stop trying to fit in IK and PTI and cultist stuff everywhere man, how many times do I tell you?
And your DHA example is beyond stupid. Nobody is taking ownership of anyone’s province. Under Article 239, changing provincial boundaries requires two-thirds approval from Parliament and two thirds from the concerned provincial assembly . Naqvi cannot redraw Pakistan with a marker during a speech .
Glad you brought this up. This was actually what your own tout Ahsan Bhoon got confused on too. So you wanna have a referendum or Article 239? Both are contradictory. Make up your mind.
Secondly, it is perfectly apt. You are taking ownership of Sindh, just look at what Mohsin Naqvi is saying.
But IDK why you are even getting into legal weeds, we all know the law can be changed on a whim here.
Creating more provinces alone will not magically fix governance, but smaller administrations with fiscal powers and strong local governments can improve it. This is basic administrative logic.
Why can't you implement stronger local governments as it is right now?
Why can't you give fiscal power right now?
Seems we are lacking in basic administrative logic since a while.
And stop dragging your "Asim bhai" into everything. I am discussing an idea, you are discussing personalities because apparently every subject in Pakistan must begin and end with your imprisoned messiah.
Who is running the country? Who proposed this idea? Who is pushing for it? Some Martians?
Even stupidity is supposed to have limits, but IK cultists seem determined to prove otherwise.
Azma Bukhari jaisi safayian aap day rahay ho...so I guess it'll be wise to look into a mirror. I haven't even mentioned IK or PTI. Would do you well to get some IK therapy...get him our of your system man...
