New York poised for first South Asian - origin and Muslim mayor as Cuomo concedes to Mamdani

The right and far-right will ALWAYS be our enemy. Where us Pakistanis fail is that we rely too much on the left and not our own people. Pakistanis NEED to be more proactive in helping our own and promoting Pakistani racial pride. We should NEVER become reliant on foreigners or ANYONE of a different race to us. Relying on other races NEVER helps.
That was the approach for the past 40-50 years of the community, and the community had limited political efforts. Also, many in the community became divided on which party they sided with in Pakistan. We need work in the reality of our lives here in the US.

IMHO, we should have strong associations to gather and focus our efforts here, but also know we need to work with other groups to be able to get our needs met. The Pakistani American population in the US is around 800,000 if I remember my research on the population projection correctly. That is far too small to be able to do things on our own. It we can still leverage this size and voting ability to have our concerns heard, if we work with like minded (ethnic or conservative leaning) communities.

Most people are pragmatic, and while we (in general) disagree with the efforts of some on the progressive left, we have to remain respectful to allow them to live their lives so we can best live our lives. So while we are members of an ethnic minority, we can also be members of other identifies that span the progressive left spectrum; we are not a monolith.

Having gone through the last few years, and 30% of the country being MAGA or solidly right wing, many in America seem to have pushed back against “identity politics” and just want to have a live and let live approach. Focusing on economic issues and general equality is the best way to get equal rights, in my opinion.

Our Pakistani associations have to be cognizant of how the culture is shifting, and learn to advocate for our beliefs, by and large, in a careful but solid manner.

So bringing this back to Zohran; he asked us to focus on our common ground and still recognized, as in his victory speech, the many ethnic backgrounds in the city.

P.s. to understand how Zohran won, we have to understand the enthusiasm and dedication of his canvassers. Zohran’s ground game was world class; flawless.

 
Last edited:
The right and far-right will ALWAYS be our enemy. Where us Pakistanis fail is that we rely too much on the left and not our own people. Pakistanis NEED to be more proactive in helping our own and promoting Pakistani racial pride. We should NEVER become reliant on foreigners or ANYONE of a different race to us. Relying on other races NEVER helps.
1762730617319.png
 
he should've stopped talking few second earlier. why poke the monster's ego?
deliver 2 or 3 election promises like affordabiltiy etc and survive all the impeachement and smear atempts..

Maybe he is getting a big head already, or maybe he is trying to emulate Newsom's attacks on Trump with an aim to rise further politically? Or could he be trying to goad Trump into cutting NYC funding to create a confrontation?

Who knows as of yet. Interesting times indeed.
 
Maybe he is getting a big head already, or maybe he is trying to emulate Newsom's attacks on Trump with an aim to rise further politically? Or could he be trying to goad Trump into cutting NYC funding to create a confrontation?

Who knows as of yet. Interesting times indeed.
Having met him years ago, when I asked him on a relatively obscure policy question he had an answer ready to go. I was surprised, but it has dawned on me since then that his positions must be positions that have been workshopped within his organization. He is the leader of a think tank of sorts, and so his actions vis a vis Trump seem calculated to win either way. Trump allows him to work, Mamdani or block him, he still is judged on the attempt. Similar to Obama early in his first term, busy with the 2008 market mess, Obama want really judge on his performance until Late in his first term. When things started going his way economically. Mamdani may not be judged on his performance until late 2027 / early 2028.
 
In a Hypothetical scenario, if a President does ended up sending troops which mayor of a City appose or lets say a Governor oppose what happen next? Can Federal forces and state police can lock horns and who's orders they will follow?
This is a lot more complicated to just answer what would happen, for that, you need the whole deal

Let's say Trump follows through with his threat and sends the National Guard to NYC, New York, as a state can issue an injunction and stop the deployment and seek a Supreme Court Emergency review (called a writ of certiorari), then the SCOTUS will decide whether the deployment was legal and constitutional or not.

The President normally cannot activate the National Guard for internal use; those powers belong to the Governor, so for the NY National Guard, that is Kathy Hochul's power. However, the president can federalize any National Guard to deal with foreign policy, as they are also a part of the United States Army. Which means the Posse Comitatus Act will apply. Which means no troop can be deployed within the US unless there is a national emergency. Now, there are 2 deployments of National Guard and active military to US cities already (LA and DC), Trump is also eyeing deployment in Chicago, Portland, and New Orleans, but the 2 deployments have with mixed results.

SCOTUS limited LA deployment in Federal Location like ICE office (Which does not count as state territories) they can't go into the street, and SCOTUS did allow Trump to use emergency power because that is the sole discretion for the President, and Congress, not State have the power to veto it, with GOP holding the Congress, Newsom basically can't do anything. But Trump did not seek the power to deploy guards and military in LA Street, I will explain below. DC is different; DC is a Federal District, which means it was under the President's Purview alone to deploy any National Guard unit. By law, the President can deploy the guard for up to 31 days, then he needs to seek Congress's approval for the stay. Again, Congress is held by the GOP, which is going to be okay; that's why there are still Guard patrolling the streets of DC.

Now as to Trump does not seek clarification of "emergency power", it's very simple, becuase either the SCOTUS side with him or not, he isn't going to call anything, because if SCOTUS don't side with him, that's obvious, he can't use them, but even if SCOTUS side with him and say all these protest warrant a national emergency, once that is out, I am pretty sure the state, all Blue state will call up their guard then Trump can't federalise anything, because the law stated, if possible, POTUS can federalise the guard, but if the guard already activiated by the state, they became unavilable, because I will need to deal with my own emergency in my own state first, then I can help federally. The best Trump could do is to pull people from Red States and send them to Blue state, but there just not enough Red State Guard, there were 4 or 5 different division with Blue state National Guard, only 3 for Red states, mostly because Red States is not as populoius than Blue States, that will strain their resource and they will need to pay for it.

So, to answer your question, if Trump sends the guard in with SCOTUS agree to Trump's emergency power, those guard he send in will be loyal to him, but as I said, if SCOTUS agree, the NY will raise its own guard and those guard will be loyal to New York Governor, and there will be a lot more NY National Guard then whoever Trump send it. Yes, it will go into a head, just like different federal agency compete with jurisdiction.
 
Maybe he is getting a big head already, or maybe he is trying to emulate Newsom's attacks on Trump with an aim to rise further politically? Or could he be trying to goad Trump into cutting NYC funding to create a confrontation?

Who knows as of yet. Interesting times indeed.
Mandani runs on an anti-Trump platform; of course, he is going to take a potshot at the man himself. Trump is public enemy no 1 if you are in a Blue State like NY. He is doing that on purpose because Democrats were seen as weak when they didn't try to fight Trump.

On the other hand, Trump doesn't really have that much on states like New York and California because those are 2 of the 4 states that received significant less than they paid in Federal Tax (The other being New Jersey and Texas). That's why Newsom is this prominent. And you are going to expect Sherill to do the same now that she won the NJ governorship.
 
A very important figure in Mamdani’s cabinet: the first deputy mayor Dean Fuleihan (the budget “guru”)





Btw, Hochul seems to back expansion on Childcare but not so much on the free buses:

 
He was running for New York. The rest were running for Israel. Simple. The people of New York aren't fools. Majority of American people are waking up to this. And Why is everyone so worried about a mayor? People need to calm down.
 
Sigh, every time I saw people talking about Mandani, Communism and Socialism

According to Britannica

1763341974287.png

1763342061851.png

NYC cannot EVER turn communist or socialist, because the Mayor does not have the power to nationalise resources and assets. On the other hand, taxing corporations and providing social benefits (Which is what Mandani ran on) is neither communist nor socialist. This is a political leaning thing (Political Left leans on social benefits), and before you say it, both Communism and Socialism do not associate with Political Left, in fact, more time than not it's the other way around, Communism and Socialism are largely associated with Nationalism, which is politically more associated to the right (although left-wing nationalism does exist, again, the prime example is Nazi Germany, but I don't think anyone, I mean, ANYONE, will call Nazi "Lefty")
 
Mamdani retaining the Police Commissioner


Young people inspired by Mamdani are going to challenge sclerotic Congressional Democrats

 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top