Russia-Ukraine War - News, Discussions & Updates

F-22Raptor said:
Russia controls less territory than they did at the beginning of the war. Ukraine has gained more territory than Russia has in the last year. Russia has lost half their armor inventory.

Who is the one coping again?🤣
Click to expand...


The Kursk Offensive was a big mistake by zelensky.
 
KingQamaR said:
Okay Armchair general. you are better informed than the retired military experts on news channels.
Click to expand...
First of all, there are NO POSSIBLE WAY for Russia to declare a win in this war strategically , because that would mean they have to occupy Ukraine in the entirety. Can they do that? Because if not, whatever left of Ukrainian control will turn to NATO, Ukraine joining NATO is a foregone conclusion. As I mentioned time and again, the only thing Ukraine didn't operate to NATO standard is their Navy, but then they are getting their Ada Class. There are literally entire NATO arsenal in Ukraine, so it would be the biggest shot in the foot for NATO not to accept Ukraine into NATO and make them run back to Russia or China for all the NATO secret they had. That's a no brainer. Becuase we aren't changing the entire NATO playbook for them.

Which mean unless Russia can either keep this war indefinitely (which is impossible) or to capture Ukraine in its entirety (which is also impossible) Even if Russia get the entire Donbas and whatever Zaporizhya they are holding, losing the rest country to NATO is a strategic failure.

Even for Donbas, you are talking about decade of war to capture the remaining 20% if we go bay the progress we had, 2024 is almost gone, and Russian advance is around 1000 sq kilometer since last november when they start pushing, there are still about 16,000 square kilometers of Donbas to go, and some of them would make places like Charsiv Yar or Avdiivka a child play, Russia is going to lose a lot more troop in the coming years, I don't think they can capture the entire Donbas before they culminated.

Now whether or not Ukraine invaded Kursk is a mistake is up for debate, I personally don't see the need to invade Kursk, but the impact was there, the only thing we don't know is how that impact the overall situation in the south to both Ukrainian and Russian, now this is an unanswerable question since it's still 2 weeks old, anyone forming any sort of opinion in this matter would be haevily depends on guess work. They may shoot themselves on the foot, or that may turn out to be a genius move, that we know some time down the road.
 
RoadAmerica said:
So when will Russia win if it’s so easy?
Cope harder
Click to expand...

Russias states aims was freedom for the Russian speaking Donbass, that is now almost complete

Anything else is a security question and if it goes to negotiations, for peace Russia will keep the liberated land and demand that Ukraine remain a neutral buffer state between Russia and NATO
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Users who are viewing this thread

  • ... and 1 more.
    • Total: 10 (members: 5, guests: 5)

    Pakistan Defence Latest

    Country Watch Latest

    Latest Posts

    Share this page

    Back
    Top