Saudang
Banned
- Sep 21, 2020
- 767
- 608
- How is this $10 billion project being funded?
Large-scale projects like this typically rely on a combination of funding sources, including multilateral institutions (such as the World Bank or Asian Development Bank), private sector investments, or financial support from the countries involved. Without clear details, it's difficult to identify the exact funding mechanism, but such projects often require a mix of public and private capital, especially in regions with complex geopolitical dynamics. - Is the project economically viable without India's participation?
India's participation is critical to the economic viability of such a project, especially in the energy sector. As one of the largest consumers of energy in the region, excluding India would significantly reduce the project's potential profitability and market reach. Without India, the project's costs and risks may outweigh its benefits, making it far less viable from an economic standpoint. - Who in Pakistan or Afghanistan believes that India would be willing to hand over energy security leverage to authorities in Rawalpindi or Kabul?
It is highly unlikely that Indian policymakers would agree to an arrangement where energy security is controlled by Pakistan or Afghanistan, given the historical tensions and security concerns in the region. Handing over such a crucial leverage point would be seen as a strategic vulnerability for India, especially with Pakistan's military establishment in Rawalpindi and the uncertain political situation in Afghanistan. - Who believes that India would agree to a one-way energy transit deal with Pakistan without a reciprocal opening of other trade barriers?
India has long been cautious about agreeing to any major transit agreements with Pakistan without broader trade concessions. A one-sided energy transit deal, where Pakistan benefits without reciprocating by opening up other trade channels, is unlikely to be acceptable to Indian negotiators. India's approach to regional cooperation tends to be comprehensive, seeking benefits across multiple sectors, not just energy.
Overall, this project seems more like a fantasy than a practical reality. Given the significant political, economic, and security challenges, the likelihood of it materializing in its current form is slim. It appears to be more of an idealistic vision than a realistic project that can be implemented under current regional circumstances.