AJK govt bans Joint Awami Action Committee, notification issued

[Goenitz]

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

Accept third party cookies

 

[iron shrapnel]

A statement to end all statements.
Time to close the thread.

 

[Goenitz]

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

Accept third party cookies

 

[Jango]

A statement to end all statements.
Time to close the thread.

View attachment 208648

Well one thing is clear...Kashmir Banega Pakistan was just an empty slogan our elites used just so that in ki dukan chalti rahay.

 

[Oscar]

Well one thing is clear...Kashmir Banega Pakistan was just an empty slogan our elites used just so that in ki dukan chalti rahay.

That is not true from the empty slogan - Pakistanis have a place in their heart for Kashmiris and their struggle overall.

But it is true from the elites saying it(and a thousand other slogans) as hollow because it was useful earlier(and will be more) for maintaining their control.

What is happening is Kashmir is just a repeat of what happened in Balochistan, in KP, in Karachi, Southern Punjab and Sindh .., and what happened in EP to an extent as well.

Simply because what people do recognize initially as elite abuse is easily hijacked to an ethnic narrative because that stokes more emotion in people of the subcontinent along with religion rather than some class rights - otherwise communism would have had a greater hold in these areas.

The military venn diagrams into the elite establishment - and then can bungle it all up.
Simplistic pigeonholes wont solve it nor will excuses for any particular player be it fauj or PTI or PPP or PML(N) politicians or bureaucrats here or in KP or anywhere.

 

[Jango]

That is not true from the empty slogan - Pakistanis have a place in their heart for Kashmiris and their struggle overall.

But it is true from the elites saying it(and a thousand other slogans) as hollow because it was useful earlier(and will be more) for maintaining their control.

What is happening is Kashmir is just a repeat of what happened in Balochistan, in KP, in Karachi, Southern Punjab and Sindh .., and what happened in EP to an extent as well.

Simply because what people do recognize initially as elite abuse is easily hijacked to an ethnic narrative because that stokes more emotion in people of the subcontinent along with religion rather than some class rights - otherwise communism would have had a greater hold in these areas.

The military venn diagrams into the elite establishment - and then can bungle it all up.
Simplistic pigeonholes wont solve it nor will excuses for any particular player be it fauj or PTI or PPP or PML(N) politicians or bureaucrats here or in KP or anywhere.

Agreed. And on the bold part...along with the reasons you enlisted, not having a proper political representation leads to such voids, which are then filled by those who are either compromised, or those who are inept and incompetent. Grassroots movements ain't always pretty, and they don't always have an Oxford PhD at their helm.

That is why political representation is important so you can steer and guide the masses and any agitation is kept contained and within the spheres of a political process.

Magr ham nay to hard state banna hai.

Senator Mushtaq was kidnapped on the way back from AJK. The guy has been through Gaza and Israel, he wouldn't think he's left that part of the world considering what's happening to him today.

 

[iron shrapnel]

Well one thing is clear...Kashmir Banega Pakistan was just an empty slogan our elites used just so that in ki dukan chalti rahay.

Sardar Aman aur Mehran elite hain ?