Melaca strait China's vulnerability? Is it true or Myth?
- Thread starter Hendarto
- Start date
This makes no sense in a reply to what i just posted. You are just typing for typings sake now
Beijingwalker
Elite Member
- Nov 4, 2011
- 76,578
- 104,150
- Country of Origin
- Country of Residence
Then why 7 out of 10 world biggest ports are in China? where are you "maritime power" India's ports?
The Top 50 Container Ports.
These are the biggest container ports in the world, the hubs that keep global trade moving.Top 50 Ports — World Shipping Council
www.worldshipping.org
- Thread starter
- #124
Well it is an old trick. China has Yu8
armyrecognition.com
Carl zha comment on choking the Straits
Not sure if India can shut off the Melaca straits because it is within the range of Chinese missiles
DSA 2024: ET80 Anti-Submarine Torpedo by Chinese firm Poly Defence
\n\n"},"name":"Sharethis"},{"type":"text","props":{"column_breakpoint":"m","content":"At the Defense Services Asia (DSA) 2024 exhibition, the Chinese defen
armyrecognition.com
Carl zha comment on choking the Straits
Not sure if India can shut off the Melaca straits because it is within the range of Chinese missiles
It's me typing just for the sake of typing?? When you say India is landlocked by Pakistan Bangladesh and China there itself you were just typing for the sake of it....
Beijingwalker
Elite Member
- Nov 4, 2011
- 76,578
- 104,150
- Country of Origin
- Country of Residence
Trying to find an Indian port in the world top 10, no luck, then top 20, no luck as well, finally found one in top 30, congradulations. What a "true maritime power" 
Maharaj ji you maybe a biggest shipbuilding nation and hats off to you for that especially when you're a semi landlocked country.... keep doing this great job....Then why 7 out of 10 world biggest ports are in China? where are you "maritime power" India's ports?
The Top 50 Container Ports.
These are the biggest container ports in the world, the hubs that keep global trade moving.
Top 50 Ports — World Shipping Council
Beijingwalker
Elite Member
- Nov 4, 2011
- 76,578
- 104,150
- Country of Origin
- Country of Residence
Then why you "true maritime power" India has no ships and ports?
Other then Pakistan and China, India is totally dependent on sea lanes. i would aregue it is more vulnerable then any major power to blockade
Again, you need to pass thru Sea of Japan for any exit for Russia.
Look at the map.......
You do know Shanghai Port handled 47.3 million TEU in 2022, right?
Shanghai Continues as Largest Container Port Handling 47M TEU in 2022
Shanghai retained its position as the world’s busiest container port for the thirteenth consecutive year in 2022 despite emerging challenges from othe...
maritime-executive.com
And that's just 1 port, and after COVID no less (China virtually close their export after COVID)
So yeah, rail link with 1.9 million TEU would work as an replacement......
It wouldn't matter, China wanted that, and if they wanted that knowing they don't have any support, that's a strategical mistake. You can dress it up as nicely as you want, that's strategic failure is the same as UN force failed to see their own operation outrun their supply line.
It didn't matter if China don't have anything. And the power of logistic would tell you China has the shortest supply line, UN (depends on which country) had the longest GLOC, that's why UN can only afford a 250,000 force in Korea, while China massed at least 2 million.
Michael
Think Tank Analyst
- Jan 5, 2024
- 498
- 783
- Country of Origin
- Country of Residence
It's hard for me to understand, where does the lovely India get their self-confidence?
I wonder if the India media really don't know the strength of the PLA? Or is it deliberately misleading the people of India?
www.mod.gov.cn
This is the official website of the Ministry of Defense of the People's Republic of China, absolutely true and valid information, and there is also an English version, and it is recommended that India netizens of PDF take a closer look at the real situation of the PLA before speaking.
At this moment, several fleets of the PLA Navy are visiting around the world. In recent years, the Chinese People's Liberation Army Navy has been second only to the United States Navy in the number of overt and undisclosed operations worldwide.
Excuse me, where is the India Navy???
I wonder if the India media really don't know the strength of the PLA? Or is it deliberately misleading the people of India?
中华人民共和国国防部
主要发布中国国防和军队建设权威信息，旨在对外传递中国军方声音，宣传中国国防政策，加强与外军交流合作，展示中国军队良好形象，促进国防和军队现代化建设。
www.mod.gov.cn
This is the official website of the Ministry of Defense of the People's Republic of China, absolutely true and valid information, and there is also an English version, and it is recommended that India netizens of PDF take a closer look at the real situation of the PLA before speaking.
At this moment, several fleets of the PLA Navy are visiting around the world. In recent years, the Chinese People's Liberation Army Navy has been second only to the United States Navy in the number of overt and undisclosed operations worldwide.
Excuse me, where is the India Navy???
We may not have as much ships or ports but we are not a prisoners of our own geography the way China is....
Never mind on Pakistan defense forum you are like a pampered puppy who's disadvantages also will be viewed as your strength no point in arguing,... I have conveyed my message and shown you the real mirror....
After this I'm not going to answer....
Hahaha Hahaha....
This is the reply you deserve...
Hakikat ve Hikmet
Think Tank Analyst
- Nov 14, 2015
- 16,498
- 42,096
- Country of Origin
- Country of Residence
Users who are viewing this thread
Pakistan Defence Latest
-
Indian general praises professionalism of Pakistani peacekeepers in South Sudan (6 Viewers)
- Latest: onlinpunit
-
-
-
-
Country Watch Latest
-
-
Iran Cyber Security and Artificial Intelligence (civilian and military) (2 Viewers)
- Latest: Immortals
-
-
-
Latest Posts
-
-
-
-
Iran Cyber Security and Artificial Intelligence (civilian and military) (2 Viewers)
- Latest: Immortals
-
New submarine detector shows ‘tremendous potential’ in South China Sea tests (4 Viewers)- Latest: Beijingwalker