krash
THINK TANK: CONSULTANT
Kalabagh Dam isnt happening for multiple reasons. One of them is the usual poor treatment of KPK where hydel payments are always 10 years behind schedule. But biggest problem with the dams is the canals that are taken out of them for irrigation , overwhelmingly in Punjab. This means Sindh loses the water that it was originally getting in the rivers.
This is why for electrical generation and some flood control, alternative dams are being built in KPK, Azad Kashmir and Northern Areas, but whose water cannot be used for irrigation canals.
1) What do the down stream canals have to do with an upstream dam?
2) Because payments are delayed you want the dam not to be built? Effectively eliminating all hydel payments from the project.... along with water storage, water security, and power generation?
3) The blame on Punjab for taking "Sindh's water" was settled once and for all back in 1991 under the Water Apportionment Accord.
4) Why cant the water from these other dams be used for irrigation canals?
There are those on the forum who justify the shabby treatment of smaller provinces in various ways, such as claiming better ROI from Punjab rather allegedly "backward barbaric vile" people living in the smaller provinces, but that is the wrong approach and an example of what's wrong with Pakistan in the first place.
You say this while contesting billions of dollars worth of investment in KPK for the Kalabagh project by the federal government.




