Iran - Israel/US War: Israel-US declare war on Iran, Iran responds

Suez Canal is man made while Strait of Hormuz is not.

Tankers are free to pass without any restriction (toll tax) in Strait of Hormuz like Strait of Malacca, Strait of Gibraltar etc as per law otherwise all the nations will start charging toll tax in world who are around the straits.
You're incorrect. Iran is acting in its own security interests within its territorial waters, which is ENTIRELY permissible by international maritime law.

There are countless examples of this.

Do you not think German commercial shipping was blockaded during WW2 by Britain?
 
The US is not self-sufficient in oil by any means. Neither do global oil prices work that way.
The United States is a net exporter of total petroleum (crude oil and refined products) as of 2026, meaning it produces more than it consumes.please check yourself also
 
Let us leave aside the problem with selective application of "international law" for one moment, just to entertain your thoughts further.

Here is a summary (mine, not AI) what International Maritime Law actually permits in this situation:

Within 12 nautical miles perpendicular to a national coastline, nations can apply the limitation of "innocent passage" upon transiting vessels (NOT "freedom of navigation", which exists beyond that distance).

"Innocent passage" allows a nation to impart reasonable security measures upon transiting vessels, including boarding, blocking, and being recompensed for said security. Iran is actually within its maritime rights to exert conditions of transit withing 12 nautical miles perpendicular to its coastline.

Indeed, it is USA that has clearly and unequivocally engaged in piracy here.
Even the 12 nautical miles is an arbitrary number stated in the UNCLOS, but Iran has never ratified the UNCLOS and hence, it is not bound to respect it. Hence, we can claim our territorial waters expand to 24 nautical miles. Why not?
 
How does this refute what I said? The Canal of Suez was not built by the Egyptians. It was first built by the Achaemenids of Persia, and later was revived and widened by the French and the British. So, if anything, the toll should go to Iran, the UK and France.
Why is Egypt taking the toll? They didn't build it. They had nothing to do with its existence.


State that law. What law is it?

You can charge the toll tax at Suez Canal if you (Iran) hold it or whoever holds it.

This is AI generated too.

"The Strait of Hormuz is not owned by a single country but is bordered by Iran to the north and Oman (specifically its Musandam Peninsula enclave) to the south. While it is a critical international waterway governed by maritime law—specifically the right of "transit passage"
 
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

CYRUS THE GREAT , must be cursing the day when he saved israelis and allowed them to return to jerusalem, later to reassemble 3000yrs later.😁 this is how ungreatful israelis are repaying Cyrus favors upon his decendents who later converted
 
You can charge the toll tax at Suez Canal if you (Iran) holds it or whoever holds it.
You're missing the point, my friend. Egypt didn't build it. So, how is it different from the Strait of Hormuz? God created the Strait of Hormuz and now we are collecting toll there.

"The Strait of Hormuz is not owned by a single country but is bordered by Iran to the north and Oman (specifically its Musandam Peninsula enclave) to the south. While it is a critical international waterway governed by maritime law—specifically the right of "transit passage"
I never said Iran "owned" the Strait of Hormuz. State the law that says that Iran cannot control the Strait of Hormuz. Most heavy tankers pass through Iranian territorial waters because the depth of the other part of the strait in its narrowest point is not enough for heavy oil tankers and containers. Iran does not own the strait, but it can certainly administer its own territorial waters.
 
Even the 12 nautical miles is an arbitrary number stated in the UNCLOS, but Iran has never ratified the UNCLOS and hence, it is not bound to respect it. Hence, we can claim our territorial waters expand to 24 nautical miles. Why not?

images (14).jpeg
 
How does this refute what I said? The Canal of Suez was not built by the Egyptians. It was first built by the Achaemenids of Persia, and later was revived and widened by the French and the British. So, if anything, the toll should go to Iran, the UK and France.
Why is Egypt taking the toll? They didn't build it. They had nothing to do with its existence.


State that law. What law is it?
The law if the jungle, not sure why people keep pointing to international law when the collective west turned a blind eye to it in their numerous aggressions. Iran should set a precedent its time to fight back against the empire or get gobbled by it.
 
The law if the jungle, not sure why people keep pointing to international law when the collective west turned a blind eye to it in their numerous aggressions. Iran should set a precedent its time to fight back against the empire or get gobbled by it.
Indeed, international law no longer means anything when Netanyahu can set the whole region ablaze with zero consequences.
 
This is AI generated too.

"The Strait of Hormuz is not owned by a single country but is bordered by Iran to the north and Oman (specifically its Musandam Peninsula enclave) to the south. While it is a critical international waterway governed by maritime law—specifically the right of "transit passage"
You've literally just proved the point being made by @ShapurII ,me, and others.

"Transit passage" or "innocent passage" as it is usually called is different to "freedom of navigation". See above posts for more clarity.
 
The law if the jungle, not sure why people keep pointing to international law when the collective west turned a blind eye to it in their numerous aggressions. Iran should set a precedent its time to fight back against the empire or get gobbled by it.
Agree. But even IF "international law" is selectively applied, Iran has not breached it.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Pakistan Defence Latest

Latest Posts

Back
Top