You say Baloch and Pashtuns need to learn "not to hate" Pakistan but forcing them into "re education camps" will only breed resentment. National unity isn’t built by crushing dissent, it’s built by listening to it, addressing grievances, and offering inclusion with dignity. What Pakistan needs to do is to choose diakogue over coercion, development over militarization, and respect over domination. The real solution isn’t camps. It’s justice, autonomy, and inclusion. You don’t unify a country by locking up its children. You do it by earning their trust and giving them economic opportunities and skills ( technical/vocational etc ).
And bringing up Japanese internment camps as a defense is flawed and frankly extremely dumn. The U.S. internment of Japanese Americans during WWII is now widely condemned as a racist and unconstitutional violation of human rights. It's taught in American schools as a national shame, not a model to follow. You want to repeat those same crimes under a different flag?
If you want to be a ethno fascist that's your choice, but atleast bring better arguments.
You read this thread title right? we are in a thread where a bus full of young kids was bombed, you still think there is room for more resentment ? remember APS ? I guess the Pakistani's have forgot them kids only remember for jazbati songs.
You tried dialog, appeasement, reconciliation for over 2 decades now, what results did that bring you? from 2002-2025, we had few years of relative peace and from 2020 onwards terrorism is on the rise again. I argued that you can build them schools, roads, nice markets, hospitals they will blow them up again and the " bechare " log will not rise up nor raise a voice against the TTP/BLA, we have seen this again and again.. How many more Pakistani's have to die before the B/P people realize that the fault lies within? rather than Truck ki batti ke tarah bas India/CIA/MOSSAD pe blame kerte raho? have you seen such behavior in other develop or civilized country ? how many Norwegians have taken money from Russians and blow up their own people? how many Russians take CIA money to kill their own kids ? But we have countless incidents of Punjabi labors identified and executed and not a Chun from the Baloch people.. This is peak Resentment within Pakistan and if this hasn't stopped using Iron fist and educational camps you will never peace in Pakistan EVER, no dua aur wazifay or 12 page ki reports will bring peace and stability to the country, only hard decisions and strong resolve can take a nation out of difficult times, we show some balls when we start kicking Afghans, now its time to build highly secure camps and make it mandatory for every Pashtoon/Baloch kid to go there, they will be educated, no need to turn it into prison, China has done similar to Uhighurs, and see the results not a single suicide attack or separatist movement exists, Uhighurs were Chinese citizens too but they were put in these educational camps because sometimes you need to do to protect the rest of the country.
Only liberal and far left see the internment camps as shame, there are millions of people in US who would agree to make more such camps for Latino's or Muslims, and even if US or any other country does that world will not blink an eye over it, Muslims in India are living under constant fear, and yet their Muslims are not violent towards their Govt, no resistance or fight... while we are Muslims, living in a Islamic country, yet we have B/P people slaughtering their own people over religion and racism... If you reflect on things by removing the lens of fake Patriotism and zabardasti ki unity things will get super clear.
I am ethno fascist for saying that govt should build reductional camps and make B/P people's kids to get education there and learn basic manners and decency and real Patriotism, learn to live their country rather than this fake persona, yeah we all Pakistani's blah blah as they say but deep down we know TTP/BLA has full support of people and locals because without their help no Terrorist Organization can last against Strong will of state. ISPR ne gana banaya tha yaad hai ? Mujhe dushman ke bacho ko Pardhana hai... I think its time to do just that, you don't want to call them Dushman? call them hostile people, what matter is their next generation raha-e-rast, because if not done than be prepared for next generation breed of Terrorist, with much more brutal tactics and effective.
